FlexiejayAnime
patreon
Romance Anime Poll!!
🕑 Added 2025-09-22 13:35:34 +0000 UTCALERT - Please read: (I'll know if you don't lol)
I want to create this poll to see where the interest lies as far as what you'd like me to watch out of these 3 Romance animes. Please vote with several things in mind.
I hand picked these series as the 3 I am most interested in starting, and out of all these I am currently the most interested in "The Fragrant Flower Blooms".
It is the newest show and also trending more than the other two currently. It would be fun to binge that!
** I WILL WATCH ALL 3 of these series EVENTUALLY! :) So fear not.
Can't wait to see what the community thinks! I'm trying to figure out when I can fit in a Romance. Because I feel like I need it haha
Also whatever wins does not mean it is an automatic watch at this time :) Again, I'm testing the waters and want to see where the interest lies! I'll chose what to do after this poll ends. Depending on the results I'll either watch one now or at the start of 2026 <3
Comments
Andrew Diseker
If you don't mind another suggestion, try to watch "The Angel Next Door Spoils Me Rotten." The first season was done some time ago, and a second season has been promised soon. This is a completely wholesome show, you really feel for the characters as they figure out their feelings, and the male lead has the best wingmom I've ever seen in an anime! The side characters are great, and there's none of the tedious triangle nonsense to derail the story.
CaptainCameron
Love is War is probably the best romcom anime MDUD has one of the best romance duos in the genre Fragrant Flower is good but I find the main characters to fall into the typical romance tropes of other romance animes. The real heros of the show are the side characters
Alpi
2nd season of my dress up darling was kinda meh. I would recommend Kaguya sama. It's peak.
B11zzard1991
People who suggested Horimiya in the comments you have my thanks. The show is so good. Kink shit had me dying.
CallmePadre7
Option 4: Toradora Option 5: Komi Can't Communicate Think I've only seen a few people react to Toradora. Crazy. If I was to make a list of "The Big 3" of Romance Anime, Toradora would be on that list 100% Maybe along with Your Lie in April. Not sure on the 3rd for me.
Ecodude
I don’t know if MDUD is the best pick for a first romance/romcom anime lol. It’s really good, but for an intro to the genre I think Kaguya is the way to go. I’ve also seen a couple of reactors run into copyright issues with MDUD, so if this is for engagement and a safer bet, Kaguya is the one. Plus, even though it’s a comedy, it’s also more mature than the other 2 (it explores quite well stuff beyond the typical tropes, Kaguya is a seinen while the others are shonen). But Tbf they’re all great, and both MDUD and Fragrant Flower does right a lot of the stuff shonen romcoms usually get wrong (the bar is quite low for these type of shows lol). That said, you’re watching all three anyway so honestly, to me it doesn’t matter too much which one you pick.
Jonas Teigen
All are great, but she should definitely experience the goat of comedy romance first, vote love is war. Its the easiest 10/10 i have given in my life.
Plushxi
My Dress Up Darling, not just for the romance, but also for the cosplay! ☺️
