Cara&Prez patreon

🚨DANGERS REPLACEMENT POLL🚨(CLOSED)

🕑 Added 2024-12-16 20:00:33 +0000 UTC

Comments

Hari Viswanathan akZNIpCfAg

Draw lesgoo

Pedro Lobo

Cmooooon Too Many Losing Heroines, a few more votes guys, we can do it!

Charles Baldwin

Romantic Killer is such an overlooked gem.

Billy Nowosielski

Looking forward to angel being watched will be diabetes injections each episode 🤣

Pedro Lobo

Yeah it can change with each poll, specially when you put so many heavy hitters in the same poll. Toradora and Oregairu are acclaimed as 2 of the greatest romances of all time, but Alya, Tomo-chan, Angel Next Door and Too Many Losing Heroines are more recent shows, so they happen to get more votes due to recency. Angel Next Door was heavily loved by many ppl who watched it, and Losing Heroines was the biggest surprise of the year for many, as almost nobody knew about it, but it surprised everyone with the quality of the show.

Cara&Prez

The reason we always re-do polls is to see what everyone wants to see at this time, for example last time Alya and Tomo Chan came in 2nd behind Dangers, now they're both bottom 2😂

Pedro Lobo

That's a good idea too... both short 1 season shows.

Pedro Lobo

OR... Just an idea... You could react to both! 😎

Trencha

Is there any consideration for watching both shows in order, since the poll is so close, rather than doing a new poll after you finish watching whichever show wins? Both Angel Next Door and Makeine are only 1 season each currently, so I think it'd make sense.

DrDrae3000

Loosing too many heroine Want Toradora to win, not only is it a good anime but everything on this list is influence by it as one the most popular OG Romcoms. but base on the ones ahead I pick Loosing too many heroine, With that said this is a good list, Tomo etc are underrated but very funny.

Cara&Prez

We might have to count the votes😂

Pedro Lobo

Damn this poll's contest is crazy... both shows with the same % since around 17% and always going up together...

Trencha

This is looking very close. I'm hoping Angel Next Door wins. I have heard great things about Makeine and I'm sure it would be a worthy winner too, but I haven't seen it yet myself and I prefer not to watch reactions to shows until I've watched them properly myself, so I have to support Angel Next Door.

Hari Viswanathan akZNIpCfAg

No Angel Next Door is losing 🥲

Nancchi

I hope Wotakoi makes it for the hell of it one day. Y’all want no high school kids? That’s the one. OR let me one up that one since this one’s done. — Golden Time

Richard Bone

I do hope Tomo Chan makes it through one day, as I think you’d have a blast watching it.

Eli Gamarra

GUYS THEY FINALLY ANNOUNCED DRESS UP DARLING SEASON 2 IN 2025!!!!

Pedro Lobo

Yeah Angel is more of a slowburn, Makeine is gold comedy since ep 1.

Hisaki

Just checked Angel and losing heroines. Nothing against all who love sweet Angels, but if its about this two im switching to heroines..1 EP got me already hooked.

Hisaki

Beside Toradora, also recommend Romantic Killer, Gekkan shoujo nozaki kun, Wotakoi, Shikimori is not just cute too. They are hilarious. And love story with yamada-kun is also a nice watch, especially when you also like games :))

Roger Powell

Especially seeing expression changes. They did it so well in S1. I doubt it will get to THAT scene, but I'd love to see Marin's expression changes that Fukuda hid.

dolo

It's absolutely the définition of Romcom. So yes.

dolo

So far the best rom(com). Can't wait too see that. I've read the manga so I know what is coming but the anime is a real added value

dolo

Komi can't communicate is cool too. Blue box is in my opinion the best romance of the year, it's so chill.

JAMES D'ALESSANDRO

I would skip Clannad.

Roger Powell

Breaking news for romcom fans 2025 is going to be another good year: My Dress Up Darling S2 scheduled for 2025. No exact date yet. Announced on the cover of this weeks issue of the magazine that publishes the manga.

Roronoa Zoro

Personally i think 100 gfs would’ve been the best choice since season 2 starts next month

Mad Man Moon

Some day we'll get My Love Story! Honestly though, I'd love to see all of these so I'm picking a (possible?) underdog - Wotakoi! A workplace story sounds like a nice change up.

Eric C

My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU is a classic

Savingstumps

Should just watch them all! (voted for WOTAKOI, Although Carol is a frickin treasure too)

KZ

Huh? When did I say that? You do realize the word “romcom” exists right?

Dooly

So it’s impossible for an anime to be both funny and romantic?

KZ

Whoever says lost heroine’s a romance should probably look up what a proper romance anime should look like. It’s a comedy.

rogueknight

Same. Oregairu is a personal favorite of mine but think for now I'm voting Losing Heroines

Kaushal Banninthaya

MAKEINE!

Pedro Lobo

Damn I would love to see a reaction to Oregairu... But as it's far from winning, I'm voting Makeine

Roger Powell

It's an interesting discussion. My short take is that it written to appeal to rom/com fans, so I'll allow it. But it almost defies genre classification.

mark angle

Snafu is an oldie but a goodie!

mellon 100

i think you guys should re run these poles after ending the next rom com to many bangers here

Maw19992

It's a good enough romance, but I wouldn't call it a romcom.

InCre

Man... Toradora only 4th place so far is getting me depressed

Hatoma

You understand what romcom is right? Cause Makeine is a comedy with romance...

Renaud Nadeau

obviously they have done most of what is considered the Peak Romcoms. There are a few others that I personally consider up there but this is where views tend to veer widely. Angel is great if you enjoy more romance focus over comedy, where say SNAFU is more comedy then romance. I would say the bottom 3 on the list are the better overall shows but I feel I would enjoy seeing their reaction to Angel. Even if I am not personally voting for it, I don't have a problem with it winning either.

Mike Baker

The voting is really close here! I think the romcom slot is safely queued up until at least summer with these.

Skilmo

Oh wotakoi c:

James Du Tiger

This has to be the hardest poll to vote in, three of them i wanted to vote for!

~Mercedeez Lee~

Oh please Wotakoi win, such a gem show. One of the best adult rom-com anime

Aleister Crowley

Toradora walked so these other shows could run. it's straight OG, peak romcom for me. in my top 3 with dangers and kaguya included.

Pedro Lobo

Is it possible for you guys to react to all of them? 😁

Pedro Lobo

It is. It's focused on comedy and romance, literally. And it's listed as comedy + romance in MAL, so...

JAMES D'ALESSANDRO

Is Makine really a rom/ com? I say no, but love the show

tracee miasco

Agreed. Angel isn’t peak compared to every romcom they’ve done like love is war, horimiya, dangers

Kurri

im not saying its a bad show. the other shows are just so much better lmao

Renaud Nadeau

Angel is a great romance show. What you mean? Do I need to have my lawyers contact you about that? 😜

Renaud Nadeau

Honestly... Just rewatch Dangers. But otherwise multiple great shows on this list.

Kurri

angel has to be an industry plant bro there is no way its beating all of these other shows

MrGiamMY999

Angel felt like a great source material that wasn’t adapted as good as it should have been, too many losing heroine is great but I feel you should watch more romances before, since it plays a lot with tropes and parody, I would recommend toradora first

soniq

Damn I don’t want to vote on any of these there not 100 girlfriends or call of the night

Roger Powell

No clinkers here, I hope all the non winners return in the next poll. Good call to save some for later.

Lark

Or it should be but doesn’t look like it

Lark

Haven’t commented on here yet, but realistically it’s a three way split in Snafu, too many losing, and Toradora. The others are pretty bland and unfinished. Toradora is decent, too many losing was actually pretty interesting just not finished, and snafu is pretty amazing in its weirdly cryptic sense.

Yellow_hat_gnome

Toradora is the only option here… Makeine is okay i guess, at least is beautiful to watch

Maleny

I want to vote Makeine, but honestly it'll only get funnier the more romance genre knowledge you guys accrue.

JustAway

tbh I'm not interested in any of these

Crofo

I’d be happy with legitimately any of these options except the one that’s in the lead rn. Angel is so bland and cookie-cutter compared to the rest

steindds

Oregairu supremacy tho

steindds

Guys these options are all peak, im happy either way!

Hari Viswanathan akZNIpCfAg

I can't choose 🥲

Kurri

the fact toradora isnt winning so far is such a robbery

Pablo

Fuck all these are too good!!

Calvin Gomez

Yes angel next door is winning

TikiJoe

THE STRUGGLE IS REAL WITH THIS ONE!? Whatever wins, im locked in with yall!!

Eli Gamarra

Setting up this poll must have been really hard cause there’s just so many good Rom-Coms.

William Cruz

Clannad for next time 😭😭😭 but I guess I’ll settle for Oregairu

Kurri

youre cooking

Eli Gamarra

It’s part of the etc

Cen Alvi

omg wotakoi please win🤞🏽😫

flowww

Voted for Alya but damn it would be nice to see you react to Makeine too

Cara&Prez

To clarify! We’ve got call of the night noted for either the Patreon exclusive poll OR later down the line as Prez is somewhat recently familiar with the first few episodes