Leakoo
Viva01 from patreon
Viva01 patreon

Hard Enough - Chapter 242 - Sharing information

🕑 Added 2024-07-23 19:00:04 +0000 UTC

Comments

HoldTightAndPretendItsAPlan

Unlikely. It would just burn them in the long run and the others would no longer trust them. More likely they have a set list of "won't trade" and "will trade" for each of them. Starters obviously being "won't trade"

HoldTightAndPretendItsAPlan

Another edit: mechnaically should be mechanically

HoldTightAndPretendItsAPlan

Edit: "Befoer I could open my mouth a roar filled the room." 'Befoer' should be 'Before' And: "“WEll family, looks like we’re have dinner now!”" The E in 'WEll' shouldn't be capital And: "Come on Kaede while we wati we can" 'wati' should be 'wait' And before was misspelled again here: "I took the food and gave a tip befoer marching into the penthouse." Might want to check whatever spell-checker you're using didn't accidentally save "befoer" as a legitimate word

Focus Armstrong

It'd be interesting if Hypnotoad learned a combination of Mind Reader and Detect , she'd become a pseudo Dodge-tank like furret while being able to land powerful hits like dynamic punch or garneted hits on evasive pokemon. Especially with Mind Reader, she'd be able to mimic the sword catching move by Bosco in the Contest.

Jeremy

So Brock is not just a military contractor remember he also has some law enforcement responsibility and organizes his Gym Trainers to patrol and assists the Rangers. So that may mean Gym Leaders are have access to nation wide information to make sure trainers have a right to be in area (we even see him check someone's credentials during his team up with Lance and the rangers). Also Forrest was able to I think arrest or black mark Damien (?) from the Charmander incident because he was a Gym Trainer so I could easily see trainer information be available to law enforcement. The extra information Brock has is in theory... (1) The full roster of Pokemon a trainer has... which while advantageous is really only a one or two time advantage once used so relatively short term. While at the same time meaning he could over analyze the persons picks like he did with Kaede... considering Pokemon that she admitted she would not use (2) Gym Leader comments may be stale and if they have been on the Ace Circuit for awhile some of the issues should have been correct or other Ace's have also realized from their own scouting. (3) Trading Information - this I give you could be egregious assuming the League intended mid-tournaments trading to occur. With Will we have already seen the League acknowledge there are aspects of the Ace Circuit culture they were not aware of and know will resolve. I would say that what Kaede is stating Bruce and friends do would be something the League would find problematic if the larger public was aware of it. If that is the case. then the League would not see any issue with Brock or Gym Leaders having trade information when doing Ace Challenges, because trading is not something they intended or expected while a tournament is going on to tailor a team.

PitrPatR

From what I can tell, the agreement is basically Gym Leaders will defend a specific place if/when necessary and assess the skills of up and coming trainers while possessing a high but limited number of pokemon. I would understand if the argument was that Brock should know about the trainers who reside in Pewter City, as they could be reasonably expected to contribute to the defense of their home. But the team composition of someone from Cianwood City or Azalea Town? Unless they are in the area, that information is of no practical use to Brock, at least in his capacity as a military contractor. There are definitely reasons for the League to track this kind of information, but their reasons don't necessarily align with the work that Gym Leaders do, especially not in how they interact with the Ace circuit. I don't buy the argument that rogue elements existing justifies this access either, because the rogue element from Indigo was Team Rocket, and they were so far off the radar that they managed to reach at least a couple of regions without anyone being the wiser. A nationalist cabal knew more than the League did, and they tolerated Team Rocket because the leader was sufficiently patriotic for their tastes until he stepped over the line, and they were still surprised by some of what was going on. Gym Leaders having access to this information did not prevent the formation of a criminal organization or help resolve it, because the records were either incomplete or nonexistent. If this were Hoenn with what appears to be parts of their military going rogue I could understand having those records available to Gym Leaders. I would argue that it would make more sense for the police organization Lance is developing to have access to these records than it would for Gym Leaders, at least in regards to Indigo. Brock's decision to pursue the top of the Ace Trainer standings are (as far as we know) unprecedented. Other Ace Trainers have to have to sustain themselves and their teams by doing the work to win and get attention to earn enough to continue on. Brock has a position where many trainers are forced to interact with him in order to progress, and it is a position he profits from holding. He may have additional duties connected to it, but given how he has been advancing without any real issue thus far, an outsider could reasonably conclude that those duties are not particularly onerous and his compensation is more than enough to support him and his team's efforts to improve. Just having the stability of a consistent revenue stream is a big advantage. Add on top of that knowing his opponent's team composition, and I can see an average person starting to doubt how level the playing field is where he is involved. I fully understand that there are reasons that these records exist and being used in some capacities. My contention is that the average person who has no special insight into how Gyms or the League function beyond their limited interactions with them might take issue with Brock's advantages that can be connected to his position working for the government. I can see how this wouldn't have come up, but now Brock's success raises the question of whether or not this is something that needs to be addressed. We saw Jinx's Mean Look damaging pokeballs raised a potential rules issue, and this situation is, to my mind at least, in a similar vein.

Singa_pore

Brock is surmising Bruce has already bought the Charizardite that Steven was selling; if Steven was selling Tyranitite it wouldn’t be a debate that Brock would have bought it if he had the means.

Jeremy

He is implying that it is possible Bruce has a megastone for Charizard his starter

Louie Roquero

Thanks for the chapter. I dont quite get this part though? "If Charizard was his starter… well it would be like a Mega stone falling into my lap for Titan." What was he implying?

Caras Galadon

Great chapter! 100% behind your work!

Caras Galadon

I don’t know if Viva01 is aware of it, but most of what Brock has access to is logical and normal for that type of world. More than that, Brock is still relatively young, and has never interacted with these part of the universe, of course he is still learning new things. But y’all need to stop seeing this story only in a battle perspective and take the great universe into which those battles are fought. Viva did a really great job outlining the history on the world and all the greater morals, culture and traditions of this world. This is a post world war, post apocalyptic world with a better end than what was expected. It’s a world that is rebuilding effectively and quickly, but also thrive on fighting and battles. There is a nuance between cheating and using the system to gather information to win. Will had abnormal advantages that went further than just information and normal trading behaviour. It was not just gathering informations, it was going above and beyond with money and a criminal organization to win. Including using pokemon that were experimented on and active slaves to win. It was not using normal means, it was using criminal assets to do so.

Caras Galadon

I would point out that Gym Leaders are more than just Gym leaders, they are leaders of their communities and have an important political role, as well as public support. They are also the first line of defence and need I remind you, a military asset. In the case of trade and team composition, I think it’s normal for a military asset to be aware of who has what in terms of firepower, especially in a region that was historically recently at war, and had known rebellious organizations acting within its borders. Need I also remind you that as much as this story is concentrated around the battlefield and pokemon fights, it’s also happening in a universe where Gym Leaders are considered the facto military assets. They have access to the information they need in case a trainer decided to go rogue and become a threat. They have access to the information they need to act as counter-terrorists and active first responders. That world was in a state of global war so intense the older don’t talk about it, in a time so recent that active combatants can still have children as young as newborns. Pokémon are sentient, sapient weapons of mass destructions. Of course the leagues will keep tracks of who has what, and of course Gym leaders, who are pillars of power for the region will have access to the information.

Jeremy

Doubt it will ever come in the story - but I wonder if any of Bruce’s friend group have used pre match trading to score a powerful / unique / rare pokemon and then after the match not trade back.

Jeremy

To answer the question about why Gym Leaders might need to know about trades. I could see it as to protect Gym Leaders from falling victim to trainers with 1 or 2 badges trading for a ringer pokemon significantly stronger and brute forcing their way to a badge. Might have been awhile ago but did not Brock mention have a pokemon die due to something similar or was it 1hko move shennanigans

Wayne

Hopefully this chapter will assuage the gripes of some readers who have been saying that Brock hasn't been prepping enough and thus deserves a loss. Here's to hoping that Brock goes the distance and defeats both Bruce and Karen.

PitrPatR

Oh definitely, at best it's probably a salty comment from a defeated opponent who somehow knows about how gyms function. I just think the possible implications are interesting to consider, which doesn't always mean interesting to read.

Matt H

Viva can, obviously, correct me if I'm wrong, but I've always assumed the information Brock sees is some amalgamation of what's regularly available to Gym Leaders and the additional records of the Guardians. I don't recall what chapter it was, but I vaguely recall a chapter where Brock realized he was showing information from the Guardians to either A.J. or Missy and tried to play it cool and move past it. That said, I think your point is well warranted and I can easily imagine this is a relatively unforeseen situation that should be addressed moving forward just like Mega Evolution. I think the simplest solution would simply be that Gym Leaders (and Elite Four members) can't officially compete as Ace Trainers (in tournaments, at least). They already have rights to challenge the Elite Four and, depending on their prestige and the nature of the challenge, they can regularly fight high level trainers so there's not really much of a loss that they could claim.

Viva01

A very good point and one that is worth discussing but it might not be too interesting if played striaght. I will have to consider it.

Viva01

sorry about that. Twmmy and I did have a run through it but it did get away on us.

PitrPatR

I wasn't comparing Brock's behavior to Will's, but that of the other ace trainers. If I look at Will's actions in relation to arranging Ace battles only and compare it to these other trainers, all I can really say is that he was a bit impatient to get started on scouting Brock. We have no indication that the trainers involved were coerced in any way, and if trading pokemon around is common/not unusual at high levels, they may have even profited from the arrangement. Will seemed to have connections in high places so I can see how it is plausible (maybe not probable, but possible) that these trainers were given these pokemon in exchange for challenging Brock. Not the kind of thing the average trainer can do, but also not one that seems too far off from what Carr and Bruce are apparently doing. Outdated notes are questionably useful. My bigger issue is why do Gym Leaders have access to anything more than the pokemon used while challenging the gyms? What possible reason is there for allowing them to know about trades? The League may have a reason to keep these records, but I would want to see more justification of why Gym Leaders get access to them. Gym Leaders are Ace Trainers, but unless there is a past example not mentioned yet in the story, none of them seem to be doing more than answering challenges, not actively trying to climb the ranks. I can see how precise information on your opponent's team makeup doesn't matter as much when it's just something that a person only does occasionally, but when someone is trying to get to the top, it gets murky about how fair having that access to information is. He has apparently had the time to keep pushing his elite team while working through a busy circuit, working with the Guardians, planning and attending various events, helping raise his siblings, and teaching his Gym Trainers and the beneficiaries of his sponsorships, just off the top of my head, all while still climbing the standings. The only place I can recall him expressing doubt about his time management is whether he is giving his sponsorship kids enough time and sometimes being surprised that something happened with his siblings that Flint took care of. Given Kaede's reaction to all the things he wasn't doing or didn't have to do because he had this information, it seems like he has been able to get pretty far just by knowing what is coming his way. Maybe Brock just has a superior work ethic, but from the outside looking in, I could easily see the case being made that he's got a good gig that also gives him an unfair advantage against opponents who have to actively monitor their competition to stay near the top.

Viva01

This but also that Mega Chraizrd... off the top of my head X is fire dragon typed instead of just fire-flying. so extra Moonblast is always a win.

Jeremy

So I think an important point to note is that Brock did not realize the issue. Which is kind of an important distinction between what Brock and Will did. Additionally, while Brock has additional notes left by Gym Leaders and trade history how important this is questionable. Bruce in theory has not been on the Gym Circuit for awhile so… long enough the Lorelei was a Gym Leader so the information is outdated. Specific trade data is important but at the same time Kaede was able to figure from experience would have concluded something similar. The biggest issue though is how Will went about gathering his information. For Brock he would have roster information and match history / notes. Will though specifically hired trainers to face Brock and barrage him with challenges to see the depth of his Ace Roster and try out different strategies. This granted more knowledge then even Brock’s gym leader information would provide and much more tailored. Final point it is possible this issue came up before and the League did not determine it was an unfair advantage. Remember even at the beginning of the story Gym Leaders could be challenged to Ace Matches. In theory the advantage of the bonus knowledge could be outweighed by the greater amount of time and focus an Ace Trainer can provide on a match. Since a Gym Leader has myriad of responsibilities.

PitrPatR

I'm not sure how to feel about the disparity of information available to Brock versus that accessible to his competition. A lot of vitriol was expressed towards Will based on behavior that we are now being told isn't that far from what those at the top of competitive battling are doing. Using a resource intended to aid Brock in properly testing trainers to prepare for competition seems like quite the advantage to have. Sure you can argue that it is a perk of taking on a lot of responsibilities, but we also haven't seen any other gym leaders pursuing the Ace circuit, which makes me wonder if they would have any opinions about him using his access to information this way. I also can't imagine that this kind of information wouldn't be more restricted going forward, given the fact that Team Rocket essentially had access to this information which would have made picking targets so easy that the hardest part would be deciding how far they could take using this information before it became obvious that the League's data was compromised. We've seen a couple things called out as only not being a problem because Brock is just a decent guy, but that just means that they there are vulnerabilities waiting for a bad actor to come along and use them. It makes Brock seem more exploitative when he doesn't bring this up.

The Tallest Tree

Glad to see Kaede helping Brock out and vice versa. Maybe this'll lead to a permanent change in his mindset towards the seriousness of this type of prep work. I'd love to see this as a growing moment for Brock as a trainer. Since the change a few chapters ago the quality has risen once again. Cheers

WelshRN

A good chapter, loving the size of it. Could definitely do with a proof read though. So many spelling and grammar mistakes.

Zeroguard

Oooh, I hope some of the moves get whacky. Also maybe Bertha will finally get to debut a Rock Wrecker, it's her signature move after all.

Matt H

My guess is some combination of being an extremely effective Dragon counter in addition to potentially providing some endurance/longevity to his team considering he's not bringing three of his four most durable pokemon (Titan, Empress, and Jorm). In the worst case Link could just get a single member of the team back on their feet, but if Link can recover his energy while in his ball he could potentially get out multiple Healing Wishes over the course of the battle. And we've already seen from Kaede how effective Healing Wish can be if used properly.

ShinLupin

will this new perspective from a veteran Ace-Trainer give Broke an Edge like he never had before? He is a quick study.

BlackRazaras

Thanks for the chapter

SailorOfHouseThunderBird

Infinite Bertha revivals?

Stan Lewis

Thanks for the chapter! I’m not entirely sure why Link would be a counter for mega charizard though. Even if it’s mega x, a rock type would be more of a counter type wise.

Qweku_v

Great chapter

Thomas Brusilovsky

Great chapter! Fun to see things from an outside perspective, at least in part.


More Creators