Leakoo
Viva01 from patreon
Viva01 patreon

Hard Enough - Chapter 239 - Learning more...

🕑 Added 2024-07-10 19:00:05 +0000 UTC

Comments

DiscoT

I will never believe that a furret of all things can stand up to more punishment than a rock type, just no.

HoldTightAndPretendItsAPlan

Edit: "If Kaede was going to keep relying on Play Rouch" Rouch sould be Rough

Dylan Sutton

I like this way better. I just don't see a part time trainer and her part time battler ace beating one of the combined league strongest trainers.

Thomas Keller

Waited until the next update came out before doing a reread. Brock felt much more in control of himself and his strategy this time around, and it showed with the more direct victory. To be honest, this isn't quite the direction I was expecting of the rewrite. In the original- timeline? let's go with timeline- when Kaede mentioned that she was going to make Brock upset, I was honestly expecting- well- more? The Ice Walrus coming out and dropping another Sheer Cold is one thing, but we'd already seen it so I was more expecting, well, Another Trick From Kaede's Bag Of TricksTM. Something that might have leaned more into the Dirtier side of the rules, especially in light of Brock's previous issues with Will, or maybe a different Move Combination that shook things up in a different way. That Kaede seemed to actually run out of cards to play that she was willing to reveal was something of a surprise tbh, though in that case I think she might have made a similar mistake to what Brock realized here. Where Brock realized that he needed to do more serious prep and battler training if he planned on properly supporting his Pokemon in the field, Kaede made the mistake of focusing more on her Personal Grudge Match than the trainer actually in front of her, leading to her needing to pull more and more trump cards out of her sleeves until she ended up drawing empty and had to rely on Furret getting into a 1v1 Melee Mash Up with The Empress Of The Mountains. In the OG timeline, Empress was more worn down and Furrett pulled out the win, but here Empress both had a healthier position to fight from *and* Brock more deliberately pressed and experimented with Aura Boosting, while also having Hypnotoad as a back up to allow Brock to unconsciously feel more secure in picking riskier plays. All in all, the rewrite timeline is a bit more dynamic imo, with both sides running better play and counter play for their teams, especially with the threat of Stealth Rocks being treated exceptionally seriously. I'm curious if this actually changes the plan for the tournament arc, as Kaede fainted in both timelines and I could see a call where Kaede's fainting essentially gets ruled as a "We're punishing people who push themselves to hard in High Level Battles that they faint, because that's unhealthy as hell, so even if they won their opponent advances in their place" thing, so Brock *may* have been intended to advance regardless if with a heavy chastisement about getting his head in the game and also putting more effort into actually preparing for his opposition. But at the same time, Brock losing (and Kaede also being removed from the tournament for health reasons possibly?) could have lead to quite the interesting exploration of other plots with Brock having much more time on his hands to be involved with them. Still, what's done is done, so time to read 240!

Spacefather

Hey Viva, you earned my respect. Subbing back!

Lányi Csaba

I really like how you managed to hammer home Brock's complecancy while still showing his skill level. It feels like he finally internalized that just because his team is strong enough to pull through, doesn't mean he is better skillwise as a battler when he doesn't prepare properly. Kaede is much more belivable and I really liked how she destoryed the stelth rock because noone actually did that before. Both Furret and her are my new favourite because of how good she was at mind games and how carefully she prepared for Brock (also, that Sable Eye was a menace). By the way, how cool was Furret dancing around Tide? Final note, are we getting some more Empress char dev? It felt like Furret may have beaten into her the reality of high level battling. If they were both fresh, I'm pretty sure Furret would have taken her out. Awesome revision all in all. I'm sure the time will come for Brock's loss but it was awesome how well you took the feedback when many (including me, mb) may have been harsher than necessary. Can't wait for what comes next.

Imef

While I'm normally glad to see Protagonists have weaknesses and lose occasionally, this really wasn't the battle for it. Reading the first version felt like reading an Ash battle. A kid who goes in without thinking and making a strategy up as he goes. This was a much better read, and I'm optimistic about the upcoming battles again.

LandoCali96

I had no problem with the original ending with the moves selected in it but the move selection makes much more sense now. The result change feels natural from the changes to the fight. Again, I had no issue with the original but the rewrite is definitely better thought out in the climax.

Retribrutus

The battle this time felt more put together and although it is nice to see Brock win in the rewrite. I would have still liked to see how you would have handled the aftermath of his loss. Since there's no big stakes here (yeah the Bruce and Carr subplots are important but they aren't End of the World important), you could have taken the direction of this Golden Week tournament to new places. Like, how his loss could be the perfect segue to focus on AJ's subplot dealing with Melvin and whether or not this fic's version of the Exeggutor trainer is ignorant to the issues plaguing the circus or is actually devious. Still that was a good conclusion to the chapter and I'm happy it sit well with you to rewrite and post.

Rhett Sellers

While this is true, Kaede is a part time trainer. She spends a lot of time doing entertainment work and contests. The level of power her pokemon have with the tip top of the ace circuit is going to be a bit uneven and show many gaps against those who train as full time professional battlers, and a counter in style is unlikely to bridge this gap in my opinion - Brocks loss will come in the future. Viva certainly wrote more into his mistakes as a trainer this time around even while showing his growth. It read much better. This can also be a learning spot for Kaede to see that although she has what it takes as a trainer to be top notch, she has to put in the long hours of hard work if she wants to compete with the best of the best. She certainly spent the time needed to analyze him and completely counter some weaknesses in his style, but there is more to training than just strategy. Just as brock is learning there is another level of preparation he needs to commit to if he wants to up his game.

Rhett Sellers

The battle in the rewrite flowed much better from going through Brock's perspective, though at times I did feel like I was reading a novel on mindset in between moves. Im not complaining about what was written, but wanted to note the tension fell off in those longer lulls in the action a little. Overall, no issue with it. I was a little surprised brock won this time around, but I do think having him lose to someone like Karen is the smarter call. I would love to see a follow up with kaede in the future to get more insight into her character. Overall, I think the changes you made were just right.

Dustin Lee

Nah just run em over. Unga bunga for the win

Rhett Sellers

While the saying 'when violence doesnt work youre not using enough of it' is mostly true, its not always the case. An ounce of cunning can often be more than enough to put a fight that is within reach into your grasp. I just fundamentally consider calling someone outsmarting their opponent 'weak shit' as wrong. Its maximizing your results and minimizing your opponents.

Dustin Lee

Then It's a damn good thing this isn't the games where that weak shit happens right?

John Schultze

I mean if you played Pokémon competitively you know that not exactly true

Dustin Lee

Power, in its raw and undeniable form, will always eclipse trickery and skill; for while cunning may weave a temporary advantage, sheer strength can forge an unyielding destiny.

Docnox

This reads so much better! If it was critical that brock lost the battle, guardivior would have been the avenue. But the fight as is makes much more sense now.

KidIcuras

Yes, yes, YES! Ahem, sorry, but yes, this is exactly what I was hoping for when Viva announced he would rewrite this chapter. The additions of more strategy on Brock's part (Stealth Rock causing Kaede issues was great as it made so much sense) and his acknowledging that a switch out with Hypnotoad was required was perfect. The chapter's flow never fell short with these additions, and in my opinion, at least, it came out all the better for them. The fact that there WERE enough mistakes on Brock's part, as well as clear issues when it comes to his mindset and even POKEMON (cough Empress cough) to then push for Brock to once again get better was handled excellently and was handled in just the right way that I am very satisfied even without the lose being "required" as I'm assuming the first version of the chapter called for in order to push this mindset upon Brock. Really, kudos Viva, and know that this fan will remain to see what plans you have moving forward. (I would have stayed without the rewrite with admittedly trepidation of just how you planned to have things go forward.)

Stein Wenaas

This is well written. I am happy to see you being comfortable in rewriting your own work. I do hope this change in outcome does not mess with your plans too much going forward, or if they do that you won’t have problems adapting. Thank you.

Carter

I liked the rewrite! Thanks for doing this!

Boobby hill

Personally win or los brock was just the frosting to this battle that showed you put in a lot work to make it entertaining while still showing kaede is a formidable opponent in this tournament setting The changes you made were better as in brock did make better decisions to use his switch outs more and empress throwing a better fight than being taken down by one super effective move with no stab thrown by an admittedly strong ass furret But perhaps that was your original intent? To get empress to see the deeper side of pokemon trainers battles where if the right strategy and training can show uo even the strongest pokemon most of the time I like the changes you made while also still liking the original chapter despite my own dislike of brocks decisions making and empress's quick downfall but again I can get if you wanted to showcase empress getting her pegs removed from under her Either way I'm still interested in where you take this till the end I Appreciate the hard work and your willingness to look at your own work and admit some changes need to be made due to some feedback from the fans The highlight for me was kaede ,while cheap as hell, is still a smart strategy to use against brock as shown against Will he has a hard against these strategies and will hopefully change post this battle How Agatha or Koga didn't already showcase this to brock remains to be seen as simply them not using these strats as something that won't happen in the kind of battles the guardians are expected to be in which is acceptable to me if that is the case Kaede is still shown to a strong rivial in the future that hopefully we'll get to see where her arc is going with bruce You're a good writer and you can make this work even if every chapter isn't a hit or some consistency issues happen Thank you for your hard work

Konan2020

I'm gonna be real and say i liked when he lost, but just because after the team rocket base attack, this entire tournament became obsolete to me, the fight were always secondary in my enjoyment of this story

David P.

This rewrite flows a lot better! It gets a win from me.

Matthew Clark

Kaede should have won. Her style is a hard counter to Brocks unpreparedness. I was happy to have him lose before and think that's more correct. It's ok for him to not be invincible in these show matches. Being champion tier doesn't mean he's above getting punished for making stupid mistakes like not researching his opponents

Empty Shelf

Personally, this rewrite doesn't really address many of the actual issues I had with the last few chapters. Brock's decision-making is a bit less inexplicable, but the mechanics are still nonsense, and I've only soured more on Kaede's gimmicks over time. I'm not going to keep harping on, it just didn't do it for me.

Davvy chappie

appreciate the rewrite but I did genuinely enjoy the fact for the narrative stand point of brock not actually winning, even with the issues. But what ever you feel is appropriate matters more for the story then a interesting take. Loved the chapter.

Eddie

rewrite is a lot better! fight makes a lot more sense, appreciate you spending the time and going back!

Jericho Rising

Having read the changes I actually think it could have made sense for there to be a loss. Unfortunately felt like a much more believable pokemon battle that I can respect.

Jericho Rising

Just finished reading the rewrite and the original again. Honestly, with how this fight played out the second time I felt a lot better about the whole thing. If Brock had lost at the end there anyways I think I could have been happy with it; Don's fight felt a lot more involved, Hypnotoad wasnt a sacrificial pawn, Empress nearly munching Sableye and the whole perfect aim situation it had going on. The play rough breaking the dp, and Furret absolutely going to town on Empress for underestimating it. If Kaede had one more pokemon I'd see Empress taking an L and Hypnotoad vs the final challenger being a rough match with how sableye blasted her.

G 21

I guess I will wait for now and not read it

Drake Werner

I don’t necessarily agree with everything in this chapter but I’ve read 238 chapters before this one. I really like your writing and I am more than willing to give a couple of chapters to see where this goes. I have a loyalty having come this far. Thank you for the chapter. Please keep writing that’s how you get better and just because you have a couple of falls and stumbles doesn’t mean you can’t get up and improve.

Kcx1

Like the conclusion.... dont like missing stealth rocks and pursuit. Also could maybe dempnstrate more glaring holes or give KAede's pokemon some better conditioning

Zromak

Weeks of dumb filler chapters and cliffhangers for some bullshit

Zach

Brock always sets up with stealth rock to punish switches. Why for just this fight did he decide that he should not once use stealth rock.

MartiMart

Really liked the Ferret with the Superhero stick and its nice that Brock is taking an L for once. I really like this Story and its nice that brock wont evolve into a mary Sue who always wins.

Hugh

I liked this chapter, I reread it and enjoyed it both times. I agree that it's weird he didn't use Stealth Rock, but he really wasn't bringing his A game. Remember all the family drama? That sort of stuff can really get into your head. Baton pass is an interesting move because it also allows you to pass a buff on to another pokemon. Ferret kept being the beneficiary of the baton pass, and I feel like if the other Pokemon had used buffs that were transferred to our furry samurai, then his defeat of empress would have made more literary sense. But, one of the amazing things about pokemon, is that it doesn't matter if you're a pseudo legendary, if you have the training, heart, and will to pursue greatness, then a simple Pikachu could stand at the highest echelons of power. Great job. Losing is a part of being a great Pokemon trainer. Great job, I enjoyed the chapter.

MyAfroAteMyDog

Seriously he lost to the furett. I don’t get it. He keeps making bad decision after bad decision. Brock should have swept

Wargrunte

Where are the stealth rocks? Brock loves using stealth rocks. He does it in almost every match he can do it in. It's almost the perfect counter to baton pass shenanigans. Why does he somehow forget to use it here, in a match that it would have worked wonders?

Alexander S

It's amazing how Brock has gotten worse at battling with pretty much every match since the Lance fight. Less methodical, less prepared. None of the subtle strategy or misdirection. Stealth rock, what's that? Totally not his best possible answer to the known in advance issue of baton pass. This feels like a mid season Ash given Brock's outfit and pokemon.

Spacefather

Yea, don't see why Brock didn't learn from the Will experience. And what's up with the KaEdE UsEd ThIs OnE tRiCk To DeFeAt BrOcK (baton pass).

Alexander S

The issue with baton pass is that it should simply be punished by the fact that you're 'wasting a turn' swapping a pokemon out. It magically granting a near full evasion and damage dodge is what's making it seem far more over tuned in this match.

Spacefather

It's because the character we loved just disappeared in front of our eyes for narrative's sake. This isn't plot armour, it's plot Achilles heel

MacDoc-101

My biggest issue with the chapter is baton pass, considering how it works in universe someone definitely would have created a move to interrupt it or something along those lines. Even more so what happened to Brock using stealth rock, would have done damage on every switch. Alongside this Brock works with the guardians his fighting and battling capabilities are quite literally a matter of national security for dealing with international issues and dealing with the team Rockets and any others. Somewhere in all this training one of his allies surely would have hammered away at such an obviously exploitable weakness that we’ve just seen I’ve been reading a few other stories e.g Seras with Pokémon Trainer Vicky where she is an OP character but she lost to Koga’s top team because his tactics beat her raw power but the loss didn’t feel cheap because the explanation behind how the battle went didn’t make it feel like a cheap loss to show the reader that she still had room to grow To be brutally honest the only reason I’m keeping the subscription is because you’re just that far ahead on Patreon

Spacefather

Unsubscribed. I'm okay with Brock losing, if it's losing to Lance/Giovanni/Mewteo. Losing to Kaede is just absurd, especially with Brock fielding arguably his strongest team in a single match we've seen. Sure, Ferret might be tough. But when you're trying to introduce realism (legendaries are more OP than normal mons, you can read belts and tells), you don't get to pick and choose. Limited switch out with unlimited baton pass? Psh. Why not have a Joey FEAR sweep Mewtwo? I truly enjoyed your work, author, and I think you generally "make good art". But I don't think you should let the narrative in your head force the story, especially when it deviates so much from everything else you've built (the realism). And I'm doing that by "voting" with my membership. I hope you read the comments and realize how many people are pointing out how unfair and unjustified and un-"the Brock we've grow to love and root for" these two chapters have been. Take some time to reflection, pause the new chapters and do a rework if you have to.

Tank45

Well said but I feel like the Will battle should’ve prepared him for this. Yes Will cheated but it was still very winnable and felt like Brock could’ve won that. He even acknowledged that he didn’t take him seriously or prepare and promised not to make that mistake again and now he’s losing to arguably a lesser trainer for the exact same reasons which is a spit in the face of the growth he should’ve had. Where he is as a character he should never be losing this battle. He should lose but lose to someone important and make that loss have actual meaning and there are multiple good choices for that which can also produce very good stories yet Viva seemed to have quite literally chosen the worst possible option for it. It does a major disservice to a lot of other trainers as well. Are we supposed to think Kaede is just as strong, if not stronger than Lance now? Just overall bad. If he had to lose give it to someone like Bruce or Karen who can actually win and be believable while also gaining a lot of momentum and progressing their arcs while giving Brock a legitimate reason to grow.

Orbnet

One hell of a Furret

Rosegfx

You know, I actually liked the fight, and I'm not surprised that Brock had to take an L at some point. I'm just wondering how Empress ended up getting knocked out so quickly? Looking back, there were no real hits between her and Furret in round one before it Passed, then Empress got off one Outrage to Blissey before being recalled. This, if I recall, is the only other time Empress was out in the field. Now in round 2 vs Furret, she gets off one Hyperbeam and one more Outrage while being hit by Play Rough, but that was enough to take her out of it? Just not seeing it with how much her natural strength was hyped previously way back when.

SailorOfHouseThunderBird

That's fair for Brock, but not for his Pokémon. Titan beat Lance's strongest Dragonite head on in a straight up 1 v 1 brawl. Bertha and Sanchez proved they could clash with Champion tier heavyweights and win. His team ARE champion tier in power and have been since the beginning of the story. That a Furret, even a lv90+ one, can beat two champion tier Tyranitar is out of pocket. I'll buy his crippling blow against Titan, that was a great strategy that they came into the fight with. The final showdown against Empress was unbelievable though.

rezo42

i liked the chapter. we have seen brock pressed harder and harder the further he climbed up the ace ranking. i kind of expected the top five to be elite four level in terms of power so Kaede giving nearly as good as she got makes sense.

enflamed9

seemed like there was a lot of emphasis put on the physical drain the repeated sheer colds were having on brock in the previous chapters of this fight, and some repeated references to how drained he was feeling might be meant as an intentional strategy to use it to physically wear down the opposing trainer....

CentaureHeart

Wow people are pissed. At least that means a lot of them care about the story

Vayes

Brock should've lvl 1 Sturdy Aron with shell bell spammed. Would've been a better circus show than losing with 6 elite pokemon and the backing of what's basically the CIA.

Alexander S

Double your pledge, you are responsible for shifting my response to this chapter from taking a break from reading to canceling all payments. Literally put your money where your mouth is.

Alexander S

It's incredible how this fight is both well written and terrible. The fight has legitimately inspired me to an emotional response, sadly that response is incredible disappointment and a desire to never give the author any more of my money. I'll check back in a couple months, maybe the explanation for this isn't cheap bullshit, but I'm not holding out much hope.

ShinLupin

Brock and Kaede just stole the show for entire tournament, doubt any other match there will be as exciting as theirs. This will also take all the attention from Bruce, which might enrage the dragon-trainer.

Stein Wenaas

To attain that level of strengt while being spread thin would imply that Kaede is better at making strong battlers than Lance himself. Because that last fight had no tricks. No buffs, no advantages and no tacktics. Just a straight up brawl, and furret still won. If this is where the autor intended to take Kaede, then that is fine, though it is coming completely out of the blue. But be aware that is the impression you are presenting.

Ixta

Personally, I immensely enjoyed 99% of that battle. I love that a "weak" pokemon like Furret can be a valid threat in this setting. I really wasn't expecting that loss though. After that Hyperbeam, it really feels like Furret should have been more tired and less able to do damage, even with Play Rough. Maybe if he was mixing in some fighting type moves and Empress couldn't avoid getting hit with 4x damage several times? It would have been interesting if they both fainted, I guess. But it's not super satisfying for them to disappear into a cloud of dust, and then bam, she's out.

Retribrutus

I initially read the chapter at work by the time this came out so I wanted to re-read it again before giving my own opinion. As the first loss in a high level battle for Brock since we've followed him in-story, I'd have to say that this was underwhelming. The healing and stall tactics that Kaede employed were fun to read since beyond Will who dirtily used any advantage that he could use to win while Kaede used moves that were by the books. However, I feel like the contentious part of the chapter is with how Brock lost. As our viewpoint Main Character, we've seen the SI be quite the competent trainer like with his victory against Lance. Yet Brock's victory against the Champion was thanks to his preparation and metaknowledge to almost perfectly guess Lance's team and strategies. Not to discredit the SI, but their victory was a result of tons of prep work. His tie to Will was due to Team Rocket rigging things against him as he didn't have his ideal and fully healed team to battle with. Both of those battles showed Brock's utmost competence as did his battle with Kaede although it was a little iffy considering some factors. The thing with writing for SIs presented as good as Brock is that you'd need to depict their losses as believable and easy to swallow for someone of his caliber. Some of the in-battle mistakes that Brock made were valid as he's allowed to make mistakes, but a few felt like they should have already been mitigated with the gathered data that got of her from the Guardians about the pokemon that had yet to be revealed to the public. To wrap things up, I enjoyed the chapter but didn't like how rushed the ending between Empress and Furret came out since it quickly resolved in a dark trench (off-screen). Compared to Lance (who he was prepared for) and Will (who he had to battle with a handicap on), Brock's loss here stings because his team is 100% healthy, he now holds a second Tyranitar in his party, and he has access to Mega Evolution. The circumstances weren't in his favor, but you can't deny that his loss to Kaede despite all of his recent achievements did sour how people perceived this chapter.

Stein Wenaas

That last machup is what I would expect if Empress threw down with Lances main dragonight. And that would be after both Brock and Lance has gotten stronger since they fought. That would mean that furret could have beaten that dragonight from the start of the story. This could make sense if Kaede had focused on furret to the exsclusion of other team members, but her roster is huge and they all seem to be elite 4-level. But not only is furret this strong, it has dedicated huge amounts of time to become a movie star and to learn the largest roster of moves I think we have seen so far, not to mention training to be a fantastic contest pokemon.

Alternative Facet

I do think people need to stop using the Lance battle as a metric for Brock's strength. Brock came into that knowing Lance's exact team and having counters, with Lance not being mentally or tactically prepared. It's quite possible that Lance would beat Brock now that he knows more of Brock's cards

Alternative Facet

You could potentially argue that because Will was the only other person he's "lost" to that uses these tactics, he only learned that he needs to be on guard from cheaters. Combined with his rock aura tendency towards stagnation, I could see it. Still, I think his allies (many of whom are tricky battlers) should have taught him the lesson. Maybe they just thought he would learn it better from real world experience. Not sure

LandoCali96

She didn't use reversal, but that would also work. At max strength, reversal ohko's a tyranitar. Play rough doesn't. That is the only issue with this loss. People are reacting like this is the worst thing ever written. It just needs to be tweaked. In a few other places too. I'm more upset with Don continuing to suck than I am furret beating Empress.

Matt H

@Jordan I mean, he SHOULD apologize to all of them after this. This battle showed that many (all?) of his Pokemon could probably perform better if they were with a different trainer. For the Pokemon that just care about being as strong as possible and winning they should absolutely be furious with Brock after this battle.

Matt H

It's especially galling that I don't I recall Titan ever demonstrating a combo move. He's supposedly very smart, Brock's starter, Bertha's boyfriend, and yet he somehow doesn't know how to do anything more complicated than use a single attacking move at a time?

Matt H

@Lando Look back at my calculations from the last chapter. At the end of the day Furret didn't use Endeavor; it used Reversal. If this story is even somewhat close to the games that means Titan and Empress are both significantly more powerful than Furret and the loss lies squarely on Brock's (and his Pokemons') utter incompetence. The alternative is that the universe of the story is sufficiently diverged from the games that a FURRET is capable of defeating both a Champion level Tyranitar and the Alpha of the Silver Ranges in the same battle. If that's true then there's a LOT of ramifications with respect to world building. Pokemon like Dragonite, Tyranitar, Salamence, and Metagross shouldn't be revered if they can be beaten by a well trained Furret (which can be found outside most cities). Why would anyone ever go through the effort of tracking down, catching, and training a "pseudo-legendary" if the weasel near your home can beat it in a straight one-on-one? We KNOW that Empress was the Alpha of the Silver Range for decades and not a Furret. The difference in this battle compared to the wilds is that the Pokemon were directed by a trainer. So the ONLY explanation is that Brock is such an inferior trainer compared to Kaede that he allowed Titan AND Empress to lose in one-on-ones against the same Furret. And even if Brock had an "off day" this is a terrible look for Lance considering he lost a match to Brock.

Rhett Sellers

Oh I have no doubt it will be written as a combination of circumstance, poor decisions, and a need for more personal growth. But I think most people here agree the fight was kinda lame in how it went down not because Brock lost but because of HOW he lost. It's funny to me that in earlier battles in the series recovery moves don't truly fully recover a pokemon as they still have some mental and physical exhaustion even if they get their HP back. Then a furret that battled what seemed like all 6 of Brock's pokemon (and got healed up twice) then went Mano a Mano with a completely fresh tyranitar and won because this was somehow the fight that Brock needed so he could have a L on his record again. It feels very Deus Ex.

Rhett Sellers

Sure he can get stronger. But the problem here is that Brock himself was battling like he is a much less experienced trainer, and Kaede films movies for a living and somehow rocks out a team meant to take on Lance.

Rhett Sellers

Don't forget Sabrina. She is a combination of trickiness and power too

Rhett Sellers

I have no doubt Brock is penciled in to get faster, stronger, better than before using this loss as an impetus. It just feels unsatisfying because Brock got a concussion right before they started the battle and only had 2 brain cells to rub together. I mean, both he and Kaede were about to fall over with like 4 pokemon fainted. Definitely not normal. It's like someone deprived them of oxygen. Veteran trainers who are competing at the top of the ace rankings shouldn't be struggling like that when they normally are fine even with their whole 6 man team going down.

Rhett Sellers

I have to disagree here. Power is a component of every battle, but just because furret isn't large doesn't mean it isn't powerful. I just think Brock caught the brain nerf, not that there was anything wrong with the battle portrayal in terms of behavior.

PurpleHart

The thing is I don't disagree with you. Losses are incredibly important to any story. Losses drive growth and allow the characters to overcome obstacles. It's actually notable that outside of gym battles, where Brock is not using his personal team, I can't remember a time that Brock actually lost any battle. The only one I can remember is Will and that was actually deemed a draw. The issue I have with this loss is that it feels so cheap. Kaede relies heavily on OHKO moves and Protect and Detect defenses which are known to be unreliable. It's hinted that she has some method of training to make them more reliable, which would actually make her a billionaire if she turned into a tutor. But also the fact that her tactics are extremely similar to Will's. Switching and heal spamming while trying to lock Brock into unfavorable matchups (granted without the illegality that Will employed) and it doesn't feel like Brock has learned anything. What good is it to show Brock's deficiency in tactics and critical thinking and then not have him learn, grow, or improve in any way? Why has he not developed counters to this stragety given that he's encountered it before? This actually should have been the reverse. Kaede tries to switch/heal spam but it is shown that Brock has been training to combat this strategy ever since Will "beat" him with it. It would show Brock's growth in tactical thinking, and allow him to move further in the tournament which still allows for a future defeat which could be a new teachable moment that he can grow from.

Rhett Sellers

I kind of have to agree that Brock felt off this entire battle. The author just wanted this moment so it was written this way. I don't hate that Brock lost, I just feel that this loss was lame, despite all the work to build it up. Brock has shown to be a better trainer than this in higher pressure situations. Mistakes can happen, but this felt like he was fumbling like a much less experienced trainer quite often. I don't keep up with Pokémon movesets, and several of the things that surprised him were things I was anticipating. It felt like the good old 'plot lowers the MC's Int stat to move the story forward'. The battle was well written, prose-wise, I'm just left dissatisfied because the result didn't feel earned to me.

LordJJJ

I am coming back to this hoping it wasn't the writing. Maybe there actually was something going on with mental manipulation of Brock. To make him make poor decisions. Ya know because "unknown forces" were attacking his family in a coordinated effort, I desperately hope there is some justification for this loss. There is no excusing the powerbalancing which was frankly awful and no secret mewtwo buffing psychic terrain like before. So I can only imagine some kinda nepharious ghost influence?!?! Maybe Agatha fixing because Karen would lose to Brock? Even though there has been no crumbs or foreshadowing for something like this and Sabrina is right there... I am just legitimately grasping at straws hoping to salvage this somehow

Alternative Facet

I think if Brock actually does grow from this, my concerns would be assuaged. It just seems like he's had other opportunities to grow after getting exposed to a more sophisticated battling style and hasn't. Maybe he's done more research on his opponents?

Matt H

Don't forget that he's, at the moment, one of only three trainers (that are known) capable of Mega Evolution as well.

Mugen23

How is anyone reading this supposed to take Brock seriously after this? We have someone that's built up to be around the same tier of trainer as the Champion/Elite four with two Tyranitars on his team get beat by a movie star furret. We've already seen Brock have issues with "trickery". Dude hasn't trained for these situations yet with all those training sessions with Koga, Karen, and Agatha or having to deal with Will?

Monzter E

Narratively brock needed a loss to grow. Emotionally i feel bad that brock lost. Personally i like this chap.

Dustin Lee

Hell f out here with that anime and games bs. The truth is that raw power will trump tricks, and it should. Miss me with that weak battling I wanna see people throw the fuck down.

Rinaldo

Best match since Lance

PurpleHart

But wait! We have to see the explanation on how Kaede trained these moves to always hit! It's explicitly mentioned in this chapter that she has some superior knowledge/training on how to make OHKO moves never miss and 100% defense moves never fail! “You really are gambling with your pokemon, aren’t you?” I said as Hypnotoad staggered back from the wall, tottering into the field once more. Kaede allowed herself a smile. “It’s risky but it’s also something we worked on,” she said. I doesn't matter that it's well established in this fic that major competitors have to combine 3-5 moves together to get super charged moves. All we need is Kaede's special training to never lose another battle! I mean, it's not really gambling with your pokemon if you can ensure that both sides of the coin have heads on them right? major /s (if it was not obvious)

Cody Adam Carroll

She had a walrein that got around the accuracy issues of sheer cold, high tempo switches, alot of anti dragon setup, and a wide variety of moves to push you into an unfavorable match up. As well as a shonen protagonist furret.

Cody Adam Carroll

Empress got solidly rocked. I wouldn't say that she was toe to toe .

LandoCali96

Pachirisu won world championship in game. Pikachu takes on legendaries in anime. Pokemon power levels aren't straight forward. Endeavor would make this fine.

Jericho Rising

Worst part of this is that Kaede has shown absolutely NO strength in this fight. She's very liable to be a joke the rest of the competition; further cementing Brocks embarrassing match.

Homeless One

Holy shit Brock finally lost a battle

Vexdt

even then you are talking about about Empress so it would have been easier to understand without her included in this fight, but Brock brought 2 of the strongest Tyranitar in this battle, with his Starter he also informed the reader/claimed having a special power up ready and then loosing like this cheaply... Sorry but that win of moviestar Furret against literal monsters feels undeserved and forced as anything I have read in a while

Matt H

On a different note, it seems like this tournament will decide who the new Elite Four member is. Brock was able to match Lance, Sabrina was able to defeat Will who Brock couldn't beat, and Lance was ready to invite Sabrina to be the next Elite Four member. We're now in a position where Karen either beats Kaede which would imply Karen is stronger than both Brock and Sabrina (which from what we've seen thus far isn't true), or Karen loses. Even if Kaede doesn't want to be part of the Elite Four that would put Karen in a similar position to Will: becoming a member of the Elite Four despite there being a clearly superior trainer out there. The outcome of this fight has some SERIOUS political implications that we haven't touched on. And yet, I think we're going to get a cop-out where Kaede isn't capable of fighting her next battle (exhaustion) so the question will be left up in the air.

Jericho Rising

That would have made things feel a bit more like he got tricked at least instead of face tanking with hypnotoad and don

Jericho Rising

Hypnotoad ran into and facetanked a tonne of moves it REALLLY should not have. Sheer Cold stomped out 2! POKEMON.

Jericho Rising

The fact that Bertha has a full on combo charge up to guarantee the 1hko does not justify a little rain making Sheer Cold guaranteed.

Jericho Rising

He did fight reaaaally poorly despite all the "prep" that apparently had been going on.

Jericho Rising

I was expecting him to lose the tournament. Makes sense honestly; just kind of expected it'd be against Tobias Darkrai~even though that's sinnoh (and the rest of his team)or some other trainer with legendaries.

LandoCali96

This Brock has always been a great trainer with lots of insight on getting the most out of pokemon but he's not a great battler. He's very straight forward. This loss has been coming. I think the biggest change that would make this much more palatable for people is if furret barely tanked hyper beam, empress was brought low by endeavor and then lost to the speed and agility. Rather than just having it charge in after tanking hyper beam.

Jericho Rising

Which is a reaaaaaally weird take.

Jordan Lopez

Here's what makes this loss even worse Brock has gotten this reminder to be better and train harder and taken the story loss already. How many times do we need to repeat the same old story beat of this point to always stay striving to get better smh. At this point Brock shouldn't be teach anyone anything because this was bad. Like Ash's Pikachu losing to treecko or snivy bad. Now what are you going to do when he has that match against Agatha??? Why hype of Brock to be a potential future champ. But hey at least the slice of life fanboys will get their drama

Jordan Lopez

Yeah what's they point of all this build up for Brock to face the rebel dragon master just for him to lose to kaeda whose basically used up all her tricks on Brock. I don't want to see Brock apologizing to his team for the up teeth time saying oh guys I let you all down I wanted us to be to go further but don't worry we're not going to let this take us down we're going to be stronger we're going to be better we're going to come back harder. We've seen that a bit too many times now

Jordan Lopez

Changing the outcome or trying to rewrite the chapter to make the loss seem better won't change the damage done. This isn't a believable loss and the way it happened kaeda should be seen as worse then will. But she won't because viva is biased of late and so we will see Brock bash himself while praise her to the moon smh. Brock isn't supposed to be so painful bad like this

Jericho Rising

What's concerning to me is that Kaede wasn't even close to elite 4 level. She's a dark horse sure but this was in fact Brocks best team. He can't exactly get stronger from here.

Gordon

Brock felt like an amateur in this and the whole fight leaves me feeling terrible, Brock shouldn't have lost that fight. Hardest fight in a while? He literally fought against lance not that long ago in the narrative timeline. Sort it out Viva

Jericho Rising

This is what really stands out

Jericho Rising

Even with a choice scarf for priority, furret~normal typed so not even with any stab. Fighting a ROCK/DARK is just asking for a beating. Even with Protect/Detect spamming. Heck EMPRESS showed that she can chain hyperbeams together. What kind of break did she even need after the first one. Just blast it again.

Jordan Lopez

That's one thing that makes it worse is the pointless unearned slice of life that will come after this. How can I respect Brock after this? How will he handle Agatha after this crap because lets not forget he has a match set up with her after this. Why hype up Brock here for him to lose to bs. I guess war training and experience doesn't matter anymore smh

Gordon

So you think a furret whilst highly trained should be able to win a knock down slug festival against a mon that has gone toe to toe against two legendaries and was the alpha of one of if not the most dangerous area in kanto/johto

Jericho Rising

But Titan went down! That felt like a loss right there, he also lost Jorm before he could mega evolve. He was literally down to his last pokemon and it was the Clutch pick of Empress, Monster extraordinaire who terrorized Mt. Silver; Rangers, basically the army of the pokemon world would steer clear of it. She fought Mewtwo to earn his respect. She's basically a legendary.

Gordon

This wasn't a team to counter him, this was a team to counter a dragon specialist. You don't think Brock would've seen any of those? He fought a literal grass specialist not even 50 chapters ago

Matt H

You know, that IS an interesting idea: Kaede being another Isekai victim. She's not bound by her situation/expectations so she can take better advantage of her knowledge and situation than Brock can without raising red flags. I still wouldn't like the most recent chapters, but it would set an interesting plot hook.

Jericho Rising

Like I understood when Titan went down, that felt like as far as the loss would go. But Empress was a bit much. If this was Tide or Link as Brocks last pokemon it'd be understandable, they aren't exactly up to the same level as the rest of brocks team.(at about Kabutops level) But 2 of Brocks objectively top pokemon(2 tyranitar) (Sanchez,Shrek, Noctowl and Hypnotoad being stronger than Jorm, aerodactyle, Shin and Selene.) it just doesn't balance well. From here Brock Literally can't get any stronger(This was literally his TOP strongest pokemon) with the exception of fully evolving Gible. He's basically been nerfed down to "kid" Brock in terms of potential; fighting random strangers on the routes.

Jericho Rising

Sums it up ya. Especially annoying for it to be such an empty ending right before a week long hiatus before next chapter.

Jericho Rising

It really does put a massive MASSIVE damper on the power scaling. Kaede hasn't even fought the elite 4 or the champion yet and is just "stronger" because of mechanic abuse. Will's cheating with Mewtwo felt less abused than this match in terms of fairness. Heck did Kaede even DO any attack moves that weren't 1 shots or reactionary?

Jericho Rising

It really was a frustrating conclusion. Especially with the sheer scale of power Brock now represents, having fought the champion, a moltress and a mewtwo. It's utterly befuddling. It honestly felt like kaede was the one with the meta pokemon knowledge because this was an all around poor showing for Brock in its entirety.

Matt H

I think what we need to take away from this fight is that the games, apparently, mean nothing and all Pokemon have similar levels of capability and potential besides Legendaries.

Matt H

I don't feel like doing the calculations for Dragonite at the moment, but for the last chapter I did some calcs for Furret and Tyranitar and the results... aren't great. And even if you take a step back this match suggests that Furret would, at least, be an opponent to MEWTWO on the level of either Titan or Empress.

Matt H

For all that Brock supposedly has technical and strategic knowledge that other trainers don't have yet he sure doesn't seem to take advantage of it. There are no combos or setups between his Pokemon. Each of them fight on their own and their movesets are that of a young child: either all attacks or all attacks and maybe one setup/utility move. And that doesn't even touch on the fact that he has DARK type aura. Of all the types Dark types are supposed to be tricky, conniving, deceptive, etc. Honestly, after this idiotic showing I hope Karen, Agatha, and Sabrina pull him aside and put him through a bootcamp to make him less of an idiot since their types all rely on forethought and being clever to some extent.

Vayes

Also, seriously? Empress, the bad bitch of Mt. Moon, losing to a showboating movie star? Empress, who likely fought off other Tyranitar and other high leveled pokemon in her territory, losing to a Furret? Deadpool has a quote about this type of writing.

Vayes

Wew so basically this is author deciding Brock, the cool calm and collected Brock, to lose via cheap and easily missable mistakes. ESPECIALLY after the opponent showboats every other move. Jeez I had just subbed last week Viva. Unnecessary losses like these make people angry.

Matt H

Nah, there was a comment about how anyone who complains about Brock losing is stupid. We're CLEARLY in the wrong and just idiots who want a power fantasy story! /s

Alex McGregor

I think I get what I feel about this chapter and fight in general, this is basically just like Ash losing fights he had no right to lose because reasons, and feels like just as much of a let down V

Odis

Also kind of crazy how Brock’s big motivational speech to the team about wanting to be the best and then later actively choosing to nerf himself when others are resorting to spying on their opponents just seems so stupid to me especially with his family and all the build up to seeing Brock in ‘peak’ form. Just hard to understand I guess.

Dustin Lee

Yeah this shit almost made me unsub ngl. I'll stick it out but I'm absolutely dreading going back to slice of life. You dropped the ball here viva.

BlissForgotten

This was a flashy battle for sure, but really kinda a super letdown. I'm not saying Brock can't lose, in fact I fully expect him to. But this wasn't him being beat. This was Brock making silly mistakes and losing it for himself or being written to do so. I guess either we will see an explanation or a rewrite in future chapters but this is a pretty low point for the novel.

Odis

Not gonna lie I think for me this was one of the bad fights. Just seemed kind of dumb how after all that he nerfs himself for what seemed like the whole tournament, no Mega, no adaptation, etc. If this is how Brock’s gonna be when he battles the best it’s gonna get really annoying to read.

Wanous

This chapter felt.....forced would be the best way I can describe it

Alex McGregor

...That was utter bullshit boss

Vexdt

TFTC but I am really disapointed about this conclusion, especially since in the end it felt like a deus ex machina so that the Brock was forced to loose again in this story A fresh Empress in my head while a wild pokemon but nevertheless near the pinnacle of power what a pokemon that is not a legendary can reach loosing like this sounds way too unbelievable Also Brock is often shown as a person with good insights and has additonally a huge amount of meta knowledge but somehow when the story needs it he behaves like a moron in matches and makes mistake after mistake for someone who fights all the time with even 1v6 battles being not a problem

David P.

Goddamn. I don’t want to leave a negative review. I hate when people do that. When they have nothing productive to say. But Furret winning after being a showboating little snit multiple times during the match just leaves such a sour taste in my mouth as a reader. I can’t imagine Empress, a literal terror of Mt.Silver who you’ve built up will one day dance with Mewtwo again, losing to one dodgy boi. I just can’t.

Eren Jaeger

65 comments telling you this fight was poorly done just about sums it up. I’m just hoping for an explanation or a rewrite, because that just wasn’t good

LordJJJ

This is the first time in this story that I am genuinely disappointed in the writing. I am fine with Brock losing, but this fight felt unjustified. There were so many moments at odds with prior power scaling and not nearly enough "mistakes" by Brock. The author just manually and clumsily overtuned Kaede's pokemon and really undertuned Brock's. Really need more show than tell and proof in the pudding here. I mean FFS Empress, EMPRESS getting 1 shot by the constantly recycled furret. You say Brocks pokemon are durable, but then completely contradict it. The writing seems rushed and forced. It seems like a plot point decided earlier but not enough tactics were thought of that might make this loss believable. To me, it seemed that most of Kaede's tactics were reset, or stall... not power-based plays. idk just feels unrealistic without more justification if you want to overturn previously established powerlevels or overturn the "durability" you are even purporting in this very chapter. I am fine with Brock losing for the over all plot arc and in bettering himself as a trainer, but that should be displayed better with the writing. Need him to actually get outplayed as his pokemon are stronger individually than he is allowing them to express. I am actually angry now that a furret's power levels (not necessarily finesse as is stated in the chapters) is as tanky, durable, and strong as Lance's Dragonite.

Sam

This just feels so unsatisfying, I’m fine with Brock losing but he’s losing because he doesn’t seem to be capable of learning and that’s not how you’ve portrayed him throughout the story. He makes mistakes yes, he runs into battle styles he’s not used to yes, but he should have learned from his experiences. It doesn’t help that Brock can’t seem to fight tricky fighting styles. Even though he trains against Agatha, Koga, Janine and Karen. It makes no sense.

Smiling Reader

Kaede should have lost. There is no doubt in my mind she should have passed out if not before Empress's hyper Beam, then directly after. Brock getting close to fainting mid fight is frustrating on so many levels but i can let it slide. But Empress should have won that fight hands down, she came into that fight at 100% while Furret was drained and tired. Yes, healing wishes healed him but he should still be drained mentally and low on energy at best he should be 70% full capability; he shouldn't have been able to beat a fresh tyranitar in a melee. That's just ridiculous.

DesertChocolate

This was a fun fight to read. I'm a little sad that Brock lost, but at least the fight felt like a grind.

Eddie

I don't have a problem with Brock losing fights, but how you went about this fight from the start made it obvious you wanted Brock to lose to show he can't win them all lol

Sean M.

That ending fight between furret and empress might need a rework, it felt super abrupt and unearned. I'm not opposed to Brock losing this fight, but a completely fresh Empress losing almost instantly against a nearly completely spent Furret pretty much off-screen?

Docnox

I’m also in the boat that furret shouldn’t of had any chance vs empress. Not with him being wrecked and there being a 200 base point disparity between the two pokemon. The training argument doesn’t fly either as she’s been the alpha pokemon in the silver ranges for over a decade. Its a neat narrative but doesn’t work at all. Again, the problem isn’t that he lost. It’s the way it happened.

Thomas Hendrix

He used it. Synchro allows Brock to sync and share senses with Titan. While powerful, it is not a direct power up like Mega evolution or Z moves If you go back to the last chapter you will see multiple instances of it while Titan is on the field.

Simplexity

I see, well then there was no point of even reading the last two chapters then. Should of just had her use Baton Pass and wrote Brock Loses the end.

PiezoVolt

Fair enough, his battle style is monotonous and just brute force.

Deltoren

I don’t know it seems like this entire fight was PIS Brock to force him to lose. He’s also gone for more and longer fights before and never had exhaustion problems. Also how is an actor have more or as much aura reserves as a gym leader. All in all this reads strongly as an author forced loss. Like ash running into 3 legendaries when he makes it to the finals

carebear90

That... doesn't make much sense. Sorry. Why would he go for Outrage in the end? Empress is specced on special moves. Why not a Dark Pulse? Why insist onDragon moves when Furret is clearly coated in Fairy type energy? That felt very, very forced. And as if Brock threw the last match-up on purpose. I don't have a problem with him losing here. He fought bad enough that he deserved to lose. Just the 'how' is very suspect... at least to me.

PurpleHart

I await the explanation on how Brock knew about the furret, and the majority of it's tricks, and did absolutely nothing to counter it. Not a single of his Pokemon know the move taunt? I will also wait on the explanation on what Kaede did to train chance moves as you've hinted at in this chapter. Not a single one failed in this entire battle to my recollection. Seems like an OP and kinda shoehorned way to win a battle and it's why I think a lot of people are upset with this result. But hey, if Brock can learn how to make every single OHKO move work 100% of the time I guess that's the future of all the battles in this fic? Fissure, Horn Drill, Guillotine left right and center. Throw in Protects and Detects every time they're facing damage and you're a guaranteed champion.

Mario Schade

It's my small hope that Brock uses this in-story now to really think about his movesets. Then that would at least make sense in the long term.

Empty Shelf

There is no prep for Baton Pass. It's unrestricted (there are no rules against it), uncounterable (it's unaffected by any moves or abilities), unpredictable (because the switched Pokemon can effectively be teleported anywhere in a line) and that's before you consider how it can transfer buffs. If he was willing to sacrifice several of his Pokemon to stack hazards, he may have slowed her down slightly, but that's a losing strategy. There's a reason why it's banned in several competitive formats, and that was before the the Author turbo-buffed it. It's a bad mechanic. @Simplexity, Pursuit doesn't work with Baton Pass. :/

thevolunteer

Ugh. Uses protect against one of the stronger hyper beams in the circuit. Use it again against The Strongest Hyper beam in the circuit, doesnt break. Sure. “Brock can loose sometimes!” Yeah when it makes sense and doesn’t rely on a system of battle that would not allow for any other strategy. There is absolutely no reason for any other strategy to exist. Every Pokémon you have would HAVE to know baton and pass. In the world Viva has written Brock absolutely should have lost. It’s just bad world building.

Mario Schade

I understand that Brock has/ is supposed to have problems against Trickster. But the whole course or the way this fight went... phew... with the ending of Empress vs. Furret... well, that just doesn't make sense to me. I don't think the strength levels fit with the rest of the story or Furret... nah... that's no Mewtwo. And Healing Wish can heal health, but I'm missing the mental factor here - I mean, that must leave its mark on Furret... The strength level of the little samurai is just artificially exaggerated. In my opinion, it just doesn't fit against Titan, Empress and even Brock with Aura and Guardian Training against Kaede... Nah. The story decision and the fight didn't convince me. The portrayal and luck of Kaede, the excessive mistakes due to exhaustion, which Kaede (apparently without aura) doesn't do and looks even more exhausted... No... sorry, I'll stick with it. This fight doesn't work for me.

Focus Armstrong

If any of Brock's Pokémon learned taunt, it would've crippled her ability to use baton passes, healing wishes and a majority of sableye. Also if any of his tyranitar had T-wave or even counter, it would've made fighting furret more manageable.

Simplexity

It's not about him losing, it's about how he loses. It's like if someone uses any type of strategy Brock just goes "?!" and drops the ball. A simple pursuit could of solved the majority of her strategy and you would think Brock would learn to do that after dealing with the last person to keep switching against him. Not to mention he fields a lot of pokemon who learn pursuit whether naturally or can be taught it. So it's like a double slap in the face. I get it he can't win the tournament sure makes sense but it just seems like all Brock has is power that's it. Screw metaknowledge doesn't matter because he is dead set on just crushing people with raw strength.

thevolunteer

I’ll keep reading, but this story no longer feels like it’s the quality where I’ll be paying for it. I’ll wait for public releases.

Narasan

Just a bit confused no complaint,but didnt titan get a new mode at some point? Or did i remember that wrong? I guess he didnt have the time to use it. Or do i remember wrong?

Simplexity

Nah I knew once he picked Jorm and Empress he was going to lose. Brock just battles the same way everytime and doesn't learn from his experiences in the past. Honestly I'm over it at this point.

Narasan

I mean,sometimes you lose? This is no games with stats,so she can just have a very good day and he a meh day. He made several small, but at this level meaningful mistakes,she only one. she had several trump cards he didnt plan for,( no prep against baton pass does confuse me) and she gambled a lot and won most. She is weaker,but near his level,and her mix of hidden trumps and gambles payed off. Brock got a powerup,so alls well i think.

geogio13

While I appreciate the fight in total, I can't help but feel that it was similar to Mass Effect in that there was this incredible build up only to snatch Defeat from the Jaws of Victory. How is it that despite being nearly beat unconscious twice and expending so much energy in previous fights as well as using Protect multiple times, it never failed once and Empress was completely defeated from being fresh? it just doesn't mesh with how the story has shown the consequences of healing.

Jordan Lopez

This was fun for a while but I'm out

PiezoVolt

Yup and Brock's overwhelming strength couldn't get past the tricks and adaptability of a season ace trainer. Did you think this fight was going to end with empress?

Kyle Donmoyer

I don't think Brock losing here was a bad call honestly. He ran into a super elite trainer who, outside of furret and blissey, had a team specifically tuned to counter him. Furret having moves such as reversal and baton pass (will get to this move later) and blissey having healing wish made them solid, meaningful additions to such a team. As well as Brock being off his game given he was dealing with burglaries and threats to his family as late as the night prior. The only thing I don't particularly like from this fight is how broken baton pass seems to be. A practically free switch that seems to be so fast that, even with showboating, that you have to predict exactly where and when it's happening to punish it. Fast enough to happen in between the start up and effect happening of an earthquake, like what. If Kayde had a flying type she would of heard earthquake and made the move worthless. And while I don't mind it, Don continuing to be Brock's designated bagger/avatar of khaine is funny to me.

Zax

I was expecting destiny bond at some point tbh

Kradish

Summary of fight: pro gamer picked up idiot ball and lost to someone spamming low kick.

PiezoVolt

Yes, that. The biggest contention in this story is the power scaling. Whether it's the games, the anime or both. Nobody will know. I just chalk it up to aura bullshit and move along. The game mindset is what seems to be Brock's problem in my opinion. That or he's green in the ace circuit scene

Amit Efraim

That is bullshit

Caras Galadon

Felt like a set up, I cannot believe that Empress who competed against Moltres could loose against a furret

Cody Adam Carroll

Brock is probably bad vs these types of battles. It seems he does best in knockout brawls and bad vs tricksters. People are also probably taking game biases into account instead of anime biases.

LandoCali96

Nah. As a dumb commentor I need to write full paragraphs that nobody wants to read but I feel are very important to write. So I can explain my dumb view of what happened in the chapter and claim that the author has no idea what they are doing even though Ive read and enjoyed the previous 200 chapters. It's all very important in the mind of dumb commentor.

CentaureHeart

I did kinda feel like the fight was doomed to be lost for Brock from the start but it was still a nice chapter!

Empty Shelf

You know, you said everything you needed to in the first sentence.

Ali Sivas

Awesome fight! I guess If dark moves can weaken psychic, play rough would of weakened outrage, Brock shouldn’t of committed, instead he should of bunkered down, all in all. A great fight, well done! The mistakes and energy felt real, especially as both made mistakes as they became exhausted

LandoCali96

I am dumb commentor. I believe hero must win every fight. Or only lose to sheer power diff like mewtwo. Nuance isnt real. Must spam 'a' button on strongest attack.

Matt H

On the plus side, maybe this means we'll get another impressive fight from Sabrina later on where she can beat the trainers Brock's unable to.

Carter

I don't like this. Honestly I'm kind of upset. I agree Kaede is a great trainer and I agree that Brock needs to get pushed once in a while. But it feels off for Brock to not have any counter to the rampant use of Baton Pass and healing wish. Has no one ever pushed Kaede this far? Also, I agree with the critiques of Empress losing to furret not really making much sense. Frankly, the way Brock used Empress was very sub par in and of itself, but I don't see how Furret did anything to win that fight. Every time Brock fights a decent trainer, he loses. To Will it was because he cheated, and with Kaede it feels like it was because Brock was totally unprepared. I will repeat, I don't need Brock to win every fight, but this doesn't feel right. Somehow when Brock loses, it always feels cheap.

Jake

That was genuinely very disappointing. I really don’t understand how that fight could have possibly gone that way… I agree with the rest of the commenters that it felt very shoehorned for the ending…

Bat

Great chapter! Close fight and I love it!

Lányi Csaba

I agree, I felt the deck was way too stacked for Kaede for her victory to feel good and earned. It would have been way more awesome if she beat Brock in a way it didn't feel like VIva pushing her.

Lányi Csaba

While its a fine idea for Kaede to beat Brock, the whole sequence of events feels a bit cheap. Not because of the tactics but rather the theme of it. I've noticed this recently, that every single even remotely challanging fight Brock is on the backfoot. His opponents always feel smarter and while he has good moves, its generally reactive to his opponents pre-planned strategies. His pokemon choices are reactive, it was keenly felt that he wasn't prepared for Kaede's tactics and baton pass and was alway playing catchup. All in all for a trainer of Brock's supposed strength and skill level he is constantly outplayed/mind gamed which breaks my and I think a lot of people's suspension of disbelief. Its like he is handed the idiot ball at almost every supposedly high level fight which not only cheapens his wins but it also makes his loss feel especially cheap. This loss felt like it shoouldn't happen because Brock didn't feel as strong/smart/skilled as he was supposed to be shown. If he loses after anticipating more than just the baton pass location trick (which I singled out because that was the only thing that felt like proper preparation)? Sure, that would be fine, awesome even. But when a LOT of times he admittedly messes up (which you could say he is tired but then why is that Kaede only makes a mistake once) it feels like it wasn't Kaede that beat him but the author. Lets not go how the furret effectively meeling Empress and then the finish felt like it was just author fiat. All in all, I am disappointed in the direction you are taking the nature and level of fights. I would rather have fewer updates for a week than you the author giving up the stories internal consistency. I didn't explein everything iin detail but I think I got the gist and the general feel this last 2 chapters evoked. Please think it a bit through because losses should be beccause Brock's opponent was better instead of the author really, really, REALLY wanting him to lose at this point.

Dustin Lee

Why tho

Donald Bagwell

I feel the overuse of things with luck was a bit campy? Furret especially as well. I have mixed feelings as while I don’t hat it, I don’t think it was the best. Especially considering Brock should have had more set up moves. I…I don’t think this was his best

Matt H

I'm not sure if any of you have played Pokerogue, but Samurai Furret felt like an enemy past wave 2000 on Endless mode: Endure tokens allowing it to survive any attack, healing up to nearly full immediately after, and then being able to one-shot any of your own Pokemon.

Petrox

Where is my pitchfork and torch? This is going to get ugly Ike Will's time. How can the queen of the silver mountain be defeated that easily?!

Baelor Hallow

All they needed to take down Mewtwo earlier was just a Furret.

Matt H

Nah, Empress was a decent enough challenge to Mewtwo by herself. Maybe just two Furrets would be enough to do what an Alpha Tyranitar and a Champion level Tyranitar couldn't do.

Empty Shelf

I don't think I can overstate how disappointed I am with this. This was a lazy and uninspired battle with a trainer we're apparently supposed to like(?) despite her cheap, lazy, and exploitative tactics. I thought Will's Mean Look shenanigans were bad enough, but this really proves how slapdash and nonsensical the battle mechanics are. If the idea point of this fight was to prove that anyone can beat Brock by spamming the right moves, it was a wild success.

AirSak2000

I don't know how to feel about this chapter. On the one hand, it feels like Kaede only won because of author-fiat, but on the other hand, I felt like this tournament arc was going to stretch too long.

Phyr

Furrets are going to take over the world, 1 furret per pseudo, a dozen furrets to a legendary should be enough....maybe 20 for the god llama himself

Eddie Markus

Ya don't know how I feel about this

KidIcuras

...I honestly don't know how to feel about this chapter. Like, on one hand, I like how Viva tied in various techniques and combos together. The constant use of Healing Wish to keep Furret in top shape being obviously one of the biggest factors of the match... But at the same time, I feel like Viva construed things to much in Kaede's favor. Mainly through the sheer constant positive results of moves that should have had at least a single failure at least ONCE. Now, the fact that such things were overcome even in the middle of the match (Sheer Cold hitting but not K.O.ing for the sole reason that Brock's pokemon were simply that strong for example) makes this not AS big an issue as it could have been... But, again, I feel like just to many mistakes were made on Brock's part throughout the match, as well as allowing Kaede to get away with to much. Like, there was just an overwhelming amount of stuff that happened throughout the match in Kaede's favor. A match that Brock went into with arguably some of his strongest mons (hell, he went in with both Titan AND Empress). I don't know, like I said, I don't know how to feel about this chapter...but I suppose that's just a credit to Viva as a writer that he can make me feel so many complex emotions about a single (if spaced out) battle. So, kudos Viva for the emotional rollercoaster of a match, lol.

Brisyngr

I dont mind the outcome too much, but i am thoroughly unimpressed with the kaede fight in terms of macthups and fight mechanics. Blissey should have been swept with just a single setup move from don, you cant tell me brock couldnt teach him ddance or swordsdance. The whole baton pass shenanigans. Furret in general somehow beeing able to compete with empress is a joke. Brocks overreliance on hyper beam and stone edge and earthquake, brock should have way better movesets for his pokemon.

Streetwise

Bull. Shit.

SailorOfHouseThunderBird

Wow. That was awesome. I'll be honest though, even up till the very end, i really didn't see that outcome happening.

Bast

Thanks for the chapter!

Matt H

Well, looks like it's Furret of all Pokemon that's going to be the new Alpha species of the Silver Ranges. Who would've thought?

PiezoVolt

Damn the baton pass spam plus healing wish spam overcame the full on offense. Great chapterm at least this shows Brock can still grow and get better both in terms of getting more diverse team and better at being a trainer since he makes a lot of mistakes in the competitive formate of this world

Andrew Bazhaw

Well the kids are going to be impressed that Empress lasted so long against Samurai furret

BlackRazaras

Thanks for the chapter

Baelor Hallow

Felt cheap, but knew he was going to lose

Simplexity

Yeah figured as much. Once it was mentioned how similar Kaede was to Will I knew Brock was going to lose.


More Creators