Leakoo
Viva01 from patreon
Viva01 patreon

Hard Enough - Chapter 238 - Titanfall

🕑 Added 2024-07-09 19:00:07 +0000 UTC

Comments

IceAir

I don't know, it didn't feel like Titan's buffs were doing anything. Pokemon still dodged most of his attacks even though he was speed boosted and they were able to tank it even though he was double attack boosed

Sebazu

The implication was Carr

gra gra

I couldn't tell a difference beyond Brock winning in the end. I really hope this wasn't a case of "audience can't handle the surrogate losing." The author said there were several things he agreed about needing to change, and I personally felt it was a strange build up only to end it here, but it's hard not to have warped perceptions about these kinds of things... hopefully it was for the best.

philip

Did kaede really sent out the robbers after brock's family?

Javidom

i liked the chapter! I mean, sure, i am annoyed that Brock lost, but that just means I was rooting for him. I feel like Brock once against fell more to failings of his aura-use, meaning the difficulty to commit in rock-type energy; he had the experience to predict what Kaede probably had on her roster, even their moves, but did not commit fast enough to the needed beatdown

Stephen

Titan was strong as always but not having him get any KOs feels sad. The Battle Bond is outstanding fun to read about and very well done. Also frustrating to see Titan fall in the semi (quarter?) finals but it was clever of Kaede and a tense battle. She is a great trainer but also a movie star. The depth of her team and training implies she has huge backing or just never sleeps. Samurai Furret is cool. Moltres and Mewtwo are a more fun and realistic rival for Titan but perhaps Titan will have a new friend after the match. Seeing Brock and Titan struggle so much the last few arcs against top 25 Ace trainers just feels off given Brock’s noted advantages and the gulf that usually exists between Elites and regular Gym Leaders and Aces. Brock feels inconsistent in power, as do several of his team. I suppose it’s payoff for Brock not hoarding secrets about training and giving out advice so freely, having so much of his battles televised. Fame has drawbacks. Yet we have seen Brock stand up to, employ, and beat similar tactics before. He trains with Sabrina who I suspect may be better at switch ins than anyone. We have seen him be burgled and shook up before and process it, get stronger, channel Aura to calm himself, fight cold. Perhaps next chapter will see Brock recall his past inner monologues? I’ve always liked your fight scenes but they can drag on some times. We have several more matches to go presuming Brock doesn’t lose over presumably many chapters. Brock has shown he could stand among Champions hundreds of chapters ago, he has credibly matched up to Legendaries. His team’s level seems to be Elite and growing. He has trained with Top 5 trainers and seems to be a match for them. It feels forced to see him still struggle against small Pokemon and tactics he has faced (stalling, switch outs, forced protects). I don’t want Brock’s win against Lance to be a fluke yet it feels like it given his shaky Ace circuit. Were rules in this tournament restricted to disallow Stealth Rock or item usage? Leftovers, Sitrus Berry, Lum Berry, sashes and bands would all have helped out here and we know Brock has considered some. Or is Brock saving those for the finals? I hope later chapters won’t have him struggle as much with teenage crooks and Ace trainers. By this stage in the story he has faced down global threats. Kinda feels like Karen, being a potential Elite 4 in the future and not above underhanded tactics, could sweep Brock. Also fun to see Sabeleye even if it wasn’t Brock who trained it up.

Thomas Keller

The difference in my mind is that she's quite obviously well trained and well thought when it comes to her strategies and tactics. Will *needed* those strategies to be a serious competitor, and whatever special training the pokemon he used had were because of other trainers or Mewtwo's help. Meanwhile Kaede *diligently* trained through Baton Pass to get the flexibility she has with it, and her enhancement of Sheer Cold requires significant thought, field development, and training, and even then it's not necessarily effective on all comers as we see after its repeated failure to secure immediate kills this match, instead acting has a- more thorough Hyperbeam essentially. It's much trickier to avoid and does massive damage, but it's still survivable at these highest levels. Will's issue is his intent and his criminal sportsmanship. Kaede is simply leaning harder into the "sport" aspect rather than the "combat" aspect of battling's "sport-combat" nature. Obviously things wouldn't work nearly so cleanly in a "winner takes all" stakes or "life or death" stakes battle, but those aren't the circumstances that this training style is meant for, so it's fine? Honestly the fact that people are able to work on and innovate such styles says a lot about reduced global/international tensions imo, that people don't think they *need* maximum violence/combat builds and can experiment with a much more sports-duelist mentality.

world-concepts-are-breaking god-is-dying

Not really, she doesn't fight in the Ace circuit and to use it against trainers woukd be unfair with how difficult her gym is already. Also it would be useless for her battles against criminals because as we have seen multiple times the grestest skill is to deploy multiple pokemons at once and command them on different tasks, there is no use for a switch out tactics that basically leaves you unguarded with fewer pokemons out fighting.

world-concepts-are-breaking god-is-dying

To those that say Brock was nerfed, I would like to remind you he was still unstable because of the thief assault. Also while Kaede might not have his same strenght, she has tactics specifically made to counter dragons, which up till now are mainly bruisers (with Dragonite being the only one that can also go in a spec attack route). Whiscash with oblivious can negate the boost of a dragon under Dragon dance while also dishing out ice beam and be very resiliant to most moves (he also knows dragon dance and outrage hinself if I'm not wrong, making him good at close range too). Furret between Reversal and Endeavor can get to some pretty nast one hit ko, if that isn't enough he can belly drum into extreem speed and then batoon pass to Whishcash. Gardevoir, well she is the bane of bruisers. Immune to dragon, capable of teleport and with huge ranged moves. Sableye, if I had to guess he can weaken bruisers with will if whisp then hide while they suffer the damage and shot sneaky attacks or simply place defensive screens and use nast moves like encore. Walrein, simply a very good ice thypes as they go, not like there are many good ones. I guess making sheer cold easier to use as long as the condition are right is fine, ice tyoes kind of need a buff like that with their terrible defenses. Blissey against dragon types I actually don't think she is that good. Yes she can stall them a lot, but they will buff in the mean time, so I guess that ia the one memeber of team shw would probably switch out, even Sableye could be switched but Blissey in particular is not so good against a dragin team. I suspect the first attack of Furret to Empress was to apply either a buff on himself or a debuff on her but for now I can only think of power up punch, but for now I still don't understand why. Still I don't think she should be undertimated saying Brock's is nerfed. Yes his nerves are not in the right place so he might have made some misplays but she isn't easy at all.

world-concepts-are-breaking god-is-dying

This is the third Elite trainer that he faced that abused switch out moves and tactics (previous ones being Will and the ghost dude). Now he already learned from previous encounters where the pokemon will appear, he just needs to prepare a counter with moves like imprison or have his pokemons learn strategies. For example if Empress learned to charge hyper beam on ferrets baton pass, then Kaede would have been forced to show her Sableye or have blissy endure what is normally a One hit Ko move. It's true that the switch is too fast to compleatly use a full move for free but still he can give them the order to charge moves so when the other pokemon is in the field and is starting to attack they already can release their attacks. Even Sanchez could have learned something similar like "charge Thunder if they use baton pass", that woukd have made the fight go more on Brock's side with him forcing Kaede to take a nasty Thunder on one of her pokemons or having to use the immune Whiscash which would have given Brock bith information of her elettric immunity and him a good switch for Don (with whiscash being very grounded and Don being able to attack from above). For now I think Brock is very weak to this kind of strategies. Mainly because this are Ace strategies meant for the competitive scene but if you think about it if Kaede were to fight in the Rocket Raid she would be useless because while Brock and others could use 6 or more pokemons to fight an all out war, her strategie would be to only have one out to switch it, making it useless, and if that isn't enough her explosive moves like Sheer cold (and I also immagine Gardevoir's Misty Explosion) would hit both allies and enemies.

Jordan Lopez

Still wasn't enough he's going to get an ear full from his mother

Jordan Lopez

Maybe we see him get the sweep here. I do agree don hasn't gotten him I'm him moment yet and after him and Brock reaffirming their bond I think it should come but then again idk the plot gets lost sometimes

Jordan Lopez

Love that you got into crunchy numbers territory here. You should also think about the fact that real like Pokemon wouldn't have the 100 level cap. It would be more of a training/ life expectancy type limitation. So bidoof arceusson could still be real

Matt H

Some fun facts if I'm doing my damage calculations correctly: Assuming: 0 IVs, no EVs, Mild nature (+SpA, -Def), and a +1 to Atk and Spd (Dragon Dance) for Titan. Perfect IVs, max EVs for Atk and Def, either an Adamant (+Atk, -SpA) or Impish (+Def, -SpA) nature for Samurai Furret, and then performing Reversal at minimum HP: Then: If Furret were Lvl 50 then Titan would need to be at least Lvl 79 (Ada) or Lvl 75 (Imp) in order to survive being KO'd under worst case (for Furret) scenarios. In that case Stone Edge from Titan would deal, at minimum, 148% (Ada) or 124% (Imp) and Dig would deal 79% (Ada) or 67% (Imp) damage to Furret. This is just an interesting thought experiment to show that we aren't anywhere even close to the realm of the games at this point. Samurai Furret wouldn't have a chance at beating Titan in the games under the best circumstances*. *Samurai Furret could theoretically score a win using F.E.A.R. strategies. In the story this would likely correspond to using a combo move of Endure + Endeavor and then following up with Quick Attack. I'd honestly prefer that to what we saw, even if it's more gimmicky in nature, since it's more "believable".

Matt H

For what it's worth, it seems like Whiscash *was* hit by Titan's EQ as a result of the Baton Pass. So it's not a guaranteed dodge, but I think the fact that Whiscash was hit was due to the ongoing nature of EQ. If it had been a move like Ice Beam, Thunderbolt, etc. I think a well timed Baton Pass (or similar move) would've negated all the damage and that's a problem from a competitive point of view.

Matt H

I think I (more or less) agree with all of you? I think Brock is in this odd situation where his theoretical knowledge of battling strategies far exceeds his constraints as a Gym Leader. I think if Brock were a Gym Leader of some type other than Rock he'd be able to take far more advantage of his "competitive" battling knowledge. But Rock types are, unfortunately, relatively limited to being bruisers in a universe where Pokemon can know more than 4 moves and battles don't strictly alternate moves between trainers. With that in mind, I think Brock had probably one of the best possible outcomes in fighting Lance as a Champion. Lance is also a bruiser, but Wallace, Steven, Cynthia, etc. would all have strategies that extend beyond a series of 1-vs-1s like Lance allowed. This is all to say that, as frustrating as it is to read, I see this fight as an example of what would happen if Brock fought an Elite or Champion level trainer *outside* of Indigo. As much as I hate to say it, given how the universe in this story has been set up I think Brock deserves to lose this fight at this point. The question (in my mind) is whether that will force Brock to find ways to lean away from the stereotype of Rock types and become more crafty, or if he'll lean into the stereotype and focus on sheer defense and overwhelming offense. I hope it's the former, but I suspect it will be the latter and we'll continue having these exceedingly frustrating fights that Brock loses to "weaker" opponents.

C&C

I think people forget that in the context of high level competition, things like 'bad periodes' or 'a bad match' exists. Even the very best have unexpected struggles because of whatever reason. Fights don't happen on paper, they happen in the real world which is why someone always has a chance. If Brock fought her 10 times, odds are he'd win 9 matches. Just this happens the one match where she has the best chance of beating him.

Gordon

Tftc I agree with The Tallest tree in that Brock has felt very underwhelming in this battle, Kaede feels like a good strong challenge but Brock has shown us in the past that he is infamous for his bide/endure strats with Sturdy

Carter

Nah I think she is good. I think it's important to realize the main character has to be challenged at some point. And she has been hyped up as a great trainer. And none of Brocks Pokemon feel squishy in this fight. They all survive 1 hit ko moves and other moves that should kill them. Moreover, Brock can't anticipate everything. I would personally never have even thought that a furret would use reversal like that.

Boobby hill

True that brings into question how gravity works on the pokemon casting it and the being affected by it and what factors affect the duration, the strength and area of gravity if blissey is using that approach Plus as you questioned what the mon can do while casting gravity

Jericho Rising

In terms of competitive pokemon I completely agree with you Shelf, but as far as this story format goes she's a dark horse showing the power of these utility/1hit ko strategy. One that perhaps we'll see others try~only to then be absolutely demolished as Brock finds a way to break the strategy...hopefully.

Jericho Rising

Or baton pass still having the pokemon coming out get hit by whatever attack the other person had prepped for them.

Definitely not a racoon

Yeah, I also feel the same for the most part. Basically it feels like the Worf effect, that Brock is struggling where he logically shouldn't to show how good of a trainer Kaede is. That said, it does make sense in a way because in most if not all high tier battles Brock's been in he's been reactionary, his only plan being to predict the opponent's picks and play around that rather than making any plan that forces his opponent to react to him.

The Tallest Tree

These past few chapters have been a struggle to get through... it just isn't believable. Kaede is a strong and versatile trainer but Brock feels nerfed. Which makes Kaedes good showing feel unearned. Which isn't nice as she seems like a fun person to fight. Great technical understanding, diverse team, and a penchant for being underestimated. I want to like her and this fight but when you have Brock's A team being manhandled it strains credulity to the point where when you have Kaede do something cool it's like 'that'd be dope, if, we were viewing this from reality and not a weird alternate universe where Brock's bruisers are so squishy' you know? I didn't explain that very well but basically, I don't feel like Kaede is too OP or that that's a bad thing, I just feel like she isn't interesting when facing this artificially weakened Brock. I want to see her face the Brock we've seen for hundreds of chapters. Where her strengths don't seem comically exaggerated but actually an amazing example of her tenacity and ability to use her opponents preconceived expectations and power against them.

thevolunteer

You’ve taken a really good approach to battling and extrapolating from game mechanics, but trainers would have absolutely no other option than to use baton pass if it worked as you have it here. Not being able to use damaging moves to punish the strategy makes it too OP. A limit on how many times you can baton pass would have to be a part of the rule set.

PiezoVolt

Brock does have his pokemon do regular gravity training so maybe that will be a factor on how well Don can theoretically fight through. And maybe the Mon using gravity can't use another move while gravity is active.

Empty Shelf

@Thomas Keller, She kind of is #3. She's protect-spamming, relying exclusively on one-hit-KO strategies, and exploiting the Baton Pass loophole to get around the hard limit on switches. She may not be a shitheel, but this is unquestionably poor sportsmanship.

Empty Shelf

@Racenrise, nope, Baton Pass is actually not affected by Pursuit. @Farirytaleguildghost, as someone already brought up, the answer was probably Sturdy. Not that it actually mattered, since both times Brock's Pokemon got KO'd immediately after without doing any further damage. @Kradish, this whole fight is nothing but cheesy, exploitative strategies. Spamming Endure, Protect, and Baton Pass to set up for one-hit-KO moves. It's all set up in such a way that Brock doesn't actually get to fight, and the rules favor her in such a way that he can't punish her.

Thomas Keller

Will's a criminally backed cheater. Kaede is 1) the trainer of his sibling's favorite pokemon star, 2) is confident but not arrogant (even if she underestimated Brock), and 3) is not being a rules exploiting asshole. She's a Technician amd a Strategist, not a shitheel, essentially.

Nyx

In a real world these are techniques performed by living beings not code. A pokemon using a move many times makes it an expert in the move and able to train out deficiencies. But on the flipside they can train to tank better than the game programmed outcomes of 5 options.

Boobby hill

Oh that's a good strat simple but sounds terrifying based on how much damage that can do using gravity would force don to be more reliant on his rock type move pool like earth quake or stone edge but his movement will be heavily restricted I can definitely see blissey getting some very good hits in Unless Don can no sell the gravity which I don't remember seing brock training with that move a lot here I don't see it happening past Don getting pissed and just using his fury as way to chip in damage while being hit on by super effective moves Taking away his flying advantage would be a good win to kaede Maybe Don can use sand storm to cloak itself and try to disrupt I gravity activation That is if she goes with that strat and not some other cheese strat like hypnosis, dream eater Or using blissey hard boiled move with her hidden ability to literally just tank everything and let brocks pokemon tire themselves out on blissey so she can sweep when they're too tired to do anything

Racenrise

Shouldnt pursuit be a natural hard counter to a baton pass centric team.

Thomas Brusilovsky

That furret is kind of a beast. I like it

Matt H

With how technical Kaede is fighting I fully expect to see Gravity make an appearance and for Don to just be dismantled while grounded.

Matt H

Not only that, Baton Pass can be used to escape from or dodge attacks unlike switches. Seems like someone *cough* Sabrina *cough* should put together a team where most if not all members can use Baton Pass or related moves. As a powerful psychic she can take advantage of her increased thinking and communication speed to make an absolutely disgusting quick-swap team. What does it matter if many of her Pokemon are less durable if she can just dodge most attacks through a Baton Pass?

Matt H

I'm trying to think, have we ever seen Don have a really impressive showing? For all his being one of Brock's elite Pokemon it's always felt as if he's just been... present most of the time. He doesn't seem to have a niche or a specialty in Brock's team. He's the slightly more durable, less technical, rock-typed flier of the team.

Fairytaleguildghost

I think for sheer cold, the condition in this world its easy to hit but requires the total and sudden freezing of the target pokemon, its basically a sudden massive drop that you can't really sustain so its either get the ko or not. If you ko the pokemon great, but if its not powerful enough to freeze a strong pokemon instantly with the drop it fails as you can't keep it at such a low temperature for longer then a second or two at most meaning the target breaks free or shakes it off like it was just a stronger icy wind perhaps. The aim of sheer cold is to drop the core temperature of the target in a sudden burst of freezing temperature, causing a ko, on larger pokemon that becomes much harder due to factors such as volume being higher so thicker pokemon like sanches, a golem, has a decent change of surviving

Petrox

I wonder why he doesn't get to compare her to Will. They battle similarly

Boobby hill

Baton pass is a bitch to deal but I can't deny it's utility Kay-day-de is setting a bar that I hope the other chumps here can reach Now Blissey going to be a hard sell don't think Don knows any super effective moves against a blissy but I don't doubt that blissey knowing ice beam, solar beam, ice punch or water pulse to tip the scales in her advantage If he can get enough dragon dances I can see Din being able to get some really good hits on that blissey but not without taking some super effective hits from her Heh how fun

Kradish

The entire concept of Baton Pass doesn't really work outside of the game (and I believe is never used in the Anime) - what even happens when the ferret uses it? Some mystical force somehow releases the pokemon (how is this selected?) from the pokeball (that is dozens of feet away?) and it does it in a way that seemingly can't be punished? If this is effectively just the trainer releasing the follow-up Pokemon, then there is no way this shouldn't count towards the swap limit. If it isn't, it just doesn't make sense? Might also just be personal preference, but I'm also not a huge fan of bouncing back and forward and left and right and swappy swappy swap some more when it comes to reading as it breaks up the flow of the battle. The limited swap numbers built in are already enough without introducing unlimited swapping with Baton Pass and similar moves. If BP was 'balanced' (as it kinda is in the games (I think)) by either the user of BP or the target of BP taking the hit anyway, it would at least be a super risky move that can be punished. The way its implemented feels like there isn't really a punish for it. Feels a bit like introducing an i-frame dodge roll into Pokemon - if you know the swap is coming and where, why is there not an attack ready to smash the target as soon as they release? Maybe its just Brock being an idiot and not punishing it? I just don't know if there is anything that can make BP and the like less crappy.

carebear90

Why would he let the Rain stay up a second time when he just could have let Titan use his Sandstorm to overpower it? He already knew she could use a wet field as a setup for Sheer Cold. The Reversal gambit was kinda obvious, too. At least to me. Furret would have had difficulty doing any reasonable damage to Titan without it. The 'mystery buff move' was obviously Endure. I've no idea why Brock wasn't expecting it. Reversal was the perfect move here, especially against a Dark/Rock type. So, why play into it? He could have easily played for time til the Disable wore off... Which it did, shortly after. I'm pretty disappointed with Brock's decision-making here. Not a great showing tactics-wise. It's still a great chapter though! Also: I still don't like that the referee uses nicknames in his announcements... :D

Tzeneth

My guess would either be the abuse of baton pass or continuing to indirectly attack Brock like with the sheer cold.

Oblivious Bookwyrm

Pretty sure that was because of Sheer Cold

PiezoVolt

Great chapter. Love that Brock is tearing apart Kaede adaptability with just overwhelming offense and is slowly climbing his way back in this match. Also good to know Sanchez has sturdy instead of galvanize as a ability

Christopher Ozouf

Good chapter.

Qweku_v

Titan fought about 3 powerful Pokémon before going down.

Bat

It came with a heavy cost. Wonder what she has planned that Brock might see as distasteful.

SailorOfHouseThunderBird

The Sturdy ability laughs in the face of OHKOs.

Empty Shelf

Yep, I was right. So many free switches from Baton Pass that the "limit" on hard switches basically doesn't matter. And with her main switch knowing Protect, it's impossible to punish. The switch-mechanics here were really not well-thought-out. Speaking of weak mechanics, I'm honestly kind of baffled by one-hit-KO moves. In-game, they're either conditional or highly inaccurate, but in this story they don't seem to have any downsides. Sheer Cold is supposed to be a 30% accurate move, but not only does it seem literally impossible to dodge since it covers the entire field, but it also fails to KO every times it hits.

Oblivious Bookwyrm

God, I loved that game. Still do actually

SailorOfHouseThunderBird

Ya know, i was skeptical at first, but if Samurai Furret HAD been allowed to use his Ninetails Demon Sword, i think Brock really would've had to just forfeit. That tiny little dude just did what Lance's strongest Dragonite couldn't do.

Qweku_v

Thx

BlackRazaras

Thanks for the chapter

Monzter E

Ohhh sh*t!!!!!

fine

Ominous chapter name


More Creators