Leakoo
Primordial Vortex from patreon
Primordial Vortex patreon

The Real Rise of Skywalker V

🕑 Added 2025-11-19 05:31:16 +0000 UTC

Comments

twilightwanderer

Before the rant, I have to say that Anakin trolling Palpatine was peak, and it was also great to see him finally bring Padme into the loop, and just how much he still trusts her. I also liked the shared vision with the original code, although I'd love to see them alter the first two lines a bit, maybe something like "Knowledge out of ignorance, Power to act despite fear" (just personal preference, I don't like the whole "there is no _, there is _" format). However, as a couple of others have already commented, I am personally uncomfortable with Anakin's positions and ideas in this chapter. While it's far from the worst I've seen in the fandom, I never enjoy when the Authoritarian Bargain shown as the best (or only) option. That said, I'm willing to give the benefit of the doubt here, because while I take issue with it from an out-of-character perspective, it makes sense in-character for someone who has basically only ever known slavery and whose experience with governments has entirely consisted of a failed Republic and a fascist Empire to come to those conclusions. Meanwhile Padme, for all her maturity, is still 14, has just suffered repeated traumatic experiences including multiple betrayals by systems and people she trusted that should have supported/protected her, and is listening to the man she loves. Honestly, I appreciate that her remaining morals are still strong enough to push back on Anakin and I'm hoping that trend continues, possibly with additional input from others as they expand their circle of friends and advisors. I also hope that as they embark on their campaign against slavery, they'll gain the experience to see that stable, lasting change is best built from the bottom up, rather than from the top down. Alternately, it's just as viable, if often more harrowing, to show characters pursuing positive ends through destructive means, and the various ways that will go wrong. For now, you're one of my favorite authors and I'll trust that there's further nuance and exploration coming. On a tangent, since I'm always down to clown on the sequel trilogy and praise (most of) the Legends EU, I think part of the problem is in the way Disney set things up in universe to allow the filmmakers to essentially remake the original trilogy, but worse. While I don't know what's in the current canon novel-wise, just looking at the films, it's disappointing that they copped out so hard on the New Republic, making it a largely irrelevant failed state in much the same way as the Old Republic was, without even the excuse of centuries of decay, or examining how the rise, rule, and fall of the Empire might have changed things. While it has plenty of its own flaws, even in this area (*cough*Thrawn*cough*), one thing I really appreciate about the Legends EU, especially in the Bantam-era novels, was how they frequently illustrated the flaws and failings of fascism and authoritarianism, while also exploring the difficulties of building new systems of government, and the pitfalls and strengths of democracy. From what I can tell, outside of Andor, the Disney canon is largely lacking in similar examinations, and in my opinion it's weaker for that.

savitar

Even if the only person he told was Yoda, it would be counterproductive. A secret is only a secret because so few people know it. Padmé and Anakin have trusted him; if he told Yoda, he would betray their trust and any chance of even slightly improving Anakin's relationship with the Jedi Order.

Karan McIntosh

Wonder if Qui-gon jin, will tell at least master yoda in private, about the queen, and anakins kids being force sensitive? They're not gonna tell the whole council, but maybe master yoda.


More Creators