Leakoo
bor902  from patreon
bor902 patreon

Harry Evans Chapter 102: British Moment

🕑 Added 2025-01-04 03:00:01 +0000 UTC

Comments

bor902

you really should have paid less attention in school haha, Imagine how long you could have enjoyed those twenty chapters if you still read out loud with your finger underneath the words ;)

Andrew

I really wish I was a slow reader. Just became a patriot member after reading on fanfiction for a while just blow through 20 chapters in the day.

bor902

Heard, will see what I can fix with it when it goes public

bor902

It's a valid critique, happy to hear it when it's explained clearly. Glad you liked the rest though. Harry is a bit of my punching bag character lol. Joey and, ironically enough Jin, are have a decent enough time.

Conor lennon

Yeah the starting bit was a bit long and jarring, made me double check if this was the right fiction. Maybe needs to be shortened just as a suggestion. Still love the rest of the chapter it's just that is a lot of paragraphs.

Green0Photon

Although I love long chapters from you, especially for this fic, the intro explanatory monologue was a bit much. 17 mostly long paragraphs that many readers are going to be frustrated with. The theme is clear and I get why you wrote it, but it feels like you accidentally wrote e.g. a reddit comment to explain the idea. Meanwhile, the theme of burying down things you can't control and putting your head in the sand is a pretty common theme. We've seen it before. And yeah it should be emphasized here, so it makes sense to have something, even of decent length. I guess it's about density. You spend a lot of text trying to explain this idea, and an uncharitable person would think you just had a bad experience at the migration office yourself. Perhaps an even worse sin is writing so much about an extraneous topic that you had to choose names for characters to make it understandable. So yeah, I'd advise cutting that down. Though obviously I still want the main idea to shine through. The past few chapters have been ripe with the theme of how hard Harry has been hit, and he's desperately trying to convince himself it's the adult thing to do to bury it down and continue with life regardless. Even using occlumency dangerously to shove his feelings down. Whether this is right of him is hard to say. A lot of the logic is sound, especially to get through your day enough to process the feelings. But the feelings must be processed. Even if afterwards you need to continue, even if the feelings aren't fully processed yet. So it's pretty clear that this is supposed to be a bit of unreliable narration. Some of Harry trying to convince himself to push it down to continue training. Which is why it's a bit annoying that this vital bit of the chapter falls flat a bit. Something like this monologue could make more sense if it was spoken or thought in character. That character wouldn't need to fully be in world too wizardly, considering Harry's characterization of thinking in adult Muggle terms, for philosophy. But so much is just truly unrelated. It would be so much more interesting if the filler instead implied more about his past life or experiences. Or a similar situation as Harry he's experienced. Or perhaps invoking more of actual philosophical theory. More directly talking about theory and philosophers, directly talking about e.g. stoicism and e.g. Marcus Aurelius. I hope this wasn't too harsh. So let's balance it with some likes. I like how it directly we go from practicing this spell to it being useful. I like Harry being an unreliable narrator who thinks he's reliable, and convinces himself it's okay to be heroic, yet those instincts are also him distracting himself. I like how he lies about having friends in other houses lol. I like how we get some growth with Hermione, and how that sets up stuff with Neville and friends. I like how we see the consequences of her not being in Gryffindor. I like seeing the comparison in personality and learning style -- and yet, it's not an unlikely chance that Hermione could also get annoyed at being corrected depending on the situation. I like Harry being a bit of emotionless jerk with dropping that advice on her. It's true, but jeez, and it's a bit of victim blaming. This isn't the time to share that advice, really. So Harry is kind of a dick here, despite the save. I'm amused how Harry disappears behind the corner. I'm amused at the back and forth with the "I lived here bit". I'd like for Harry to get some self awareness instead of feeling so superior. Being so used to being surrounded by children, or even how he interacts with some adults, makes him seem like he's treating people like NPCs. He had a bit of a shock with Tonks seeing through him and telling about needing Occlumency lessons. So this characterization is all setup for that. Especially with how Harry really ends up being selfish here. He really treats it as a way to feel better about himself, not about making sure Hermione is okay. It's quite awful to force some advice on someone and disappear, and we can really tell how bad his mental state is. We have got some excellent fodder for character growth.


More Creators